Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

7 Barb. 388

Drake v. Price

New York Supreme Court

Decided November 5, 1849

New York Supreme Court · decided 1849-11-05

The complaint alledged that the defendants were the sole acting executors of the last will and testament of Gilbert Hunter, deceased ; that in said will the testator, among other things, directed his executors to place and keep $5000 at interest as the share of Julia Ann Smith, now the above plaintiff Mrs. Drake, and to receive such interest and pay the same over yearly, and every year, to her during her natural life, and then to divide the principal among her lawful heirs;…

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently July 1878

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1849-11-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court, Barculo, J.

¶1The defendants, executors of Hunter’s will, invested $5000 for the plaintiff, Mrs. Drake, pursuant to directions of the will, to pay over to her the interest. This they have done for several years, retaining Jive per cent of the interest moneys as commissions, after having had full commissions on settling the estate. The plaintiffs sue to recover back four per cent, contending that only one per cent can lawfully be taken. I so decided at the special term.

¶2I still think the decision right. The case of Valentine v. Valentine, (2 Barb. Ch. Rep. 430,) is an authority for saying that commissions are not to be taken in two capacities, i. e. as executors and as trustees. And although in Vanderheyden v. Vanderheyden, (2 Paige, 287,) full commissions were allowed upon the annual receipts and disbursements, yet it was solely upon the ground that the annual rests, made for the purpose of charging interest against the guardian, were to be considered annual settlements of the accounts. It seems to me that this case is a mere continuance of the executor’s duties, and that having received full commissions on $5000, they can only take one per cent upon the proceeds of the fund, and are not permitted to begin anew every year.

¶3The judgment should be affirmed with costs.

¶4Judgment affirmed.

/7/barb/388 · .json · Public domain