Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

7 Johns. 159

Love v. Palmer

New York Supreme Court

Decided November 15, 1810

New York Supreme Court · decided 1810-11-15

THIS was an action of debt. The plaintiff declared ~an a bond, dated the 7th of August, 1809, in the penalty of 200 dollars, conthtioned to indemnify the plaintiff against all costs and damages, that shall or may arise against him, on account of his not taking N. Palmer to prison, on account and by- virtue of a Ca. sa. which the plaintiff had in his hands, issued out of the supreme court, in favour of Reuben Leonard and Rufus Leonard; and the defendants bound themselves to…

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently January 1895

1 state decisions

Relies on Dole v. Bull

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1810-11-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1It is apparent that the bond, in this case, was tabtn as an indemnity for an escape, then in contemplation, and not for an' escape which had previously happened. The plaintiff had the prisoner, and the ca. sa. in his possession when he took the bond, and it was given for the deliverance of the prisoner from custody. It was accordingly void in law, for the party was not bailable. The case of Dive v. Manningham, (Plowden, 60.) is an early and solemn determination upon the point. That was an action of debt, upon a bond of indemnity, given to the plaintiff, as sheriff, for the delivery out of prison of a prisoner, whom the sheriff had taken in execution for a debt; and on demurrer, the bond was held to be void, both by the common law, and under the statute of 23 Hen. VI. c. 9. which we have adopted, (sess. 24. c. 28. s. 13.) as being taken for ease and favour, or by colour of his office, in other form than that prescribed by the statute. The same doctrine is recognised in r • merous subsequent cases, and is not now to be q- ¿stioned. (10 Co. 99. Cro. Eliz. 66. 199. Yelv. 19'. . 2 Bulst. 213. 2 Johns. Cas. 245.) Judgment must, therefore, be given for the defendants.

¶2Judgment for the defendants.

/7/johns/159 · .json · Public domain