Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

7 R.I. 476

Garraty v. Duffy

Supreme Court of Rhode Island

Decided September 6, 1863

Supreme Court of Rhode Island · decided 1863-09-06

Trespass for breaking and entering the plaintiff’s close, bounded southerly by Lockwood street, in Providence, tearing down his fence, and crossing his land in one place, excavating and carrying off his soil in another part of his close, building a wall and house on, or so near it that the eave-boards and roof of the house projected over the same. Plea, the general issue, with liberty reserved by agreement to give any special matter in defence under it.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1863-09-06

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently November 2007

5 state decisions

20186318701880189019001910192019301940195019601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Ames, C. J.

¶1 There is no foundation for the defendant’s claim, that because the reservation in Grinnell’s deed to Ahern, and. in Ahern’s to the plaintiff, is in general terms, he can change his mode of access to the well at his convenience, after the mode reserved had been fixed by the assent of the original parties, as we must presume that it was, by several years exclusive use of a particular way. Indeed, if we are to believe the testimony of Grinnell, the gangway along the north line of the lot, close to the back fence, was the very way to the well which he had reserved, as well as used. The defendant chose to close this up by an addition to his house, without the consent of, or even consultation with, the owner of the other lot. By blocking up the- old way, he certainly did not acquire a right jfco open a new one. A change of way can only be effected by agreement of the owners of both lots. The plaintiff is entitled to damages in this action for the breaking through his fence and traversing his lot in the unauthorized manner which the evidence discloses; but the projection of the eaves of the addition to the defendant’^ house over the plaintiff’s land, and the consequent damage to it by the water drip therefrom, is not a proper subject of claim in trespass, but in trespass on the case.

¶2*478 Judgment for the plaintiff for twenty dollars damages, and as the case comes here by the defendant’s appeal from the Court of Common Pleas, with costs.

/7/ri/476 · .json · Public domain