Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

7 Tenn. 136

Cocke v. Stuart

Tennessee Supreme Court

Decided July 1, 1823

Tennessee Supreme Court · decided 1823-07-01

In Error. This was an action of assumpsit, brought in the Circuit Court of Jefferson County. The declaration contained two counts. The first set forth specially that a certain John Hall, in the year 1810, had brought his action of covenant in the County Court of Grainger, against David Stuart, and prosecuted the same to a judgment for three thousand and sixty-four dollars, besides cost of suit.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 1943

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1823-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Brown, J.

¶1delivered the opinion of himself and judges Haywood and Whyte’against the operation of the release in this case, because the matters recited in the deed of release are they on which alone the release could operate. It would be effectual against a further prosecution of the suit in equity mentioned in the release. Also, against any cause of action then existing, in consequence of William Cocke having signed the deed of conveyance, on which the action against Stuart had been brought.

¶2But there being no cause of action existing against John Cocke at the time of giving the release for or on account.of the $ 1,000 sued for in this action, it was wholly inoperative as pleaded.

¶3The cause of action arose when the Supreme Court gave judgment in favor of Stuart in the case, Hall against him, in 1819. The release was given in 1811, and cannot operate prospectively so as to defeat an action, the cause of which might afterwards arise.

¶4Because a release is the giving or discharging of a right of action, which a man hath or may claim against another, or that which is his.” Bac. Ab. Tit. Release, 680 ; Gwilliam’s Ed. same book, 704, letter h, 706 i, 709, 710 k, 712 1. Judgment affirmed.

Peck, J. did not sit, having been of counsel for Stuart.
/7/tenn/136 · .json · Public domain