Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

70 Ill. App. 199

C. Henning & Sons v. Williams

Appellate Court of Illinois

Decided May 24, 1897

Appellate Court of Illinois · decided 1897-05-24

<p>1. Bill of Exceptions—Should not Omit Matters that May Have Affected the Result.—Where an examination of the record reveals that an account book introduced in evidence is not incorporated in the bill of exceptions and the court is not able to say that the contents of the book were not important enough to materially affect the result, the judgment can not beheld to be against the weight of the evidence.</p>

Affirmed · Decided 1897-05-24

Mr. Justice Waterman

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court.

¶2This was an action of assumpsit, the propriety of the judgment obtained in which depends almost entirely upon disputed questions of fact, concerning which the evidence was conflicting.

¶3An examination of the record reveals that an account book introduced in evidence is not incorporated in the bill of exceptions.

¶4We are not able, from an examination of the testimony, to say that the contents of this book were not so important as to materially affect the result, and consequently can not know that, upon the evidence presented to the court below, the conclusion there reached was incorrect.

¶5The omission of the contents of this book from the record is urged by appellee as a reason why the judgment should be affirmed.

¶6To this no satisfactory reply has been made.

¶7Perceiving in the record no error warranting a reversal of the judgment, it is affirmed.

/70/illapp/199 · .json · Public domain