Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

70 N.H. 88

46 A 457

Reed v. Prescott

Supreme Court of New Hampshire

Decided December 5, 1899

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · decided 1899-12-05

Bill in Equity, alleging that the plaintiff is heir to one half of the estate of James G. Thompson, of which the defendant James-L. Wilson is administrator; that the estate was represented as insolvent, and á commissioner appointed whose report was accepted by the probate court.

Relies on Gale v. Nickerson · Metcalf v. Gilmore · Clough v. Fowler

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1899-12-05

How this case has been cited

Cited by 14 later decisions — most recently November 1956

14 state decisions

601899190019101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Parsons, J.

¶1 The plaintiff’s remedy is an application to the probate court to vacate the decree accepting the commissioner’s report which it is alleged was obtained by fraud. Moore v. Carpenter, 63 N. H. 65, 66; Clough v. Moore, 63 N. H. 111, 113; McDermott v. Hayes, 60 N. H. 9; Ayer v. Messer, 59 N. H. 279, *89 280; Metcalf v. Gilmore, 59 N. H. 417, 437; Warner Bank v. Clement, 58 N. H. 533, 534; Flanders v. Lane, 54 N. H. 390, 392; Judge of Probate v. Lane, 51 N. H. 342, 348; Morgan v. Dodge, 44 N. H. 255, 258; Kimball v. Fisk, 39 N. H. 110, 120; Parker v. Gregg, 23 N. H. 416, 424, 425; Symmes v. Libbey, Smith (N. H.) 137; Gale v. Nickerson, 144 Mass. 415; Waters v. Stickney, 12 Allen 1. If there is fraud or error in the decree against which the plaintiff is entitled to relief, the probate court, on her petition, can modify or vacate the same and do justice in appropriate proceedings. Ayer v. Messer, supra. If upon such petition and hearing it shall be found that the commissioner’s allowance of the disputed claims was obtained by fraud, further hearing can be ordered before him without extension of time for presentation of claims; or, if necessary, the commission may be set aside, and a new one issued which shall be deemed and taken as the original commission. P. S., c. 192, ss. 4, 13; Peabody’s Petition, 40 N. H. 342; Parker v. Gregg, supra.

¶2 Bill dismissed.

All concurred.
/70/nh/88 · .json · Public domain