Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

71 Cal. 238

Ex parte Zeehandelaar

California Supreme Court

Decided October 29, 1886

California Supreme Court · decided 1886-10-29

<p>Contempt—Refusal of Witness to Answer—Question must be Pertinent. — The refusal of a witness to answer a question not pertinent to the issues on trial is not a contempt; and an order adjudging him guilty of a contempt which fails to show the pertinency of the question is invalid.</p> <p>Id. — Impertinent Question.—Pending the trial of an action, the petitioner was called as a witness, and asked by the judge whether any one connected with the office of an attorney for one of the parties, who had been present at the trial, had made any statements to him as to what had transpired during its progress. The petitioner refused to answer, and was adjudged guilty of contempt, and imprisoned. He thereupon sued out the present writ of habeas corpus to be discharged from the imprisonment. Neither the petition for the writ nor the return thereto contained any allegation showing the pertinency of the question to the issues on trial. Held, that the refusal to answer the question was not a contempt.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1886-10-29

How this case has been cited

Cited by 19 later decisions — most recently October 1961

19 state decisions

50188618901900191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Morrison, C. J., concurring.

¶1The petition in this case shows that the petitioner was called upon to testify in a certain divorce case pending in the Superior Court of San Francisco, wherein one Alice Hinkle was plaintiff and P. Hinkle the defendant, and in the course of the proceedings the petitioner was asked the following question by the judge of the court: “I desire to know if Mr. Hinkle or Mr. Lowenthal, or anybody connected with Mr. Lowenthal’s office who has been present during the trial, has made to you any statements as to what transpired during the progress of the trial.”

¶2This was the first and only question asked the peti- . tioner, which the petitioner declined to answer, and was thereupon imprisoned for contempt of court for such refusal.

¶3It does not appear for what purpose the question was asked, and it is not clear how an answer thereto could have been material to the divorce case then on trial. Unless the matter sought to be elicited from the witness had some bearing on the case on trial, or was in some manner material to matter in issue, it is hard to understand what right the court had to inquire into it, or how the refusal of the witness to answer it constituted a contempt of the court.

¶4By section 1211, Code of Civil Procedure, it is provided that “when a contempt is committed in the immediate view and presence of the court or judge at chambers, it may be punished summarily, for which an order must be made reciting the facts as occurring in such immediate view and presence, adjudging that the person proceeded against is thereby guilty of a contempt,” etc.

¶5*241If all the facts set forth in this case are admitted to be true, it does not follow therefrom that the defendant was guilty of a contempt of court in declining to answer the question, and that he thereby committed a contempt of court.

¶6I am of opinion that the petitioner should be discharged, and it is so ordered.

/71/cal/238 · .json · Public domain