Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

71 Miss. 576

Fant v. Dunbar

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided October 15, 1893

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1893-10-15

From tbe chancery court of Noxubee county. I-IoN: W. T. Houston, Chancellor of the second district, presided by interchange. In 1871, S. P. Fant died intestate, leaving as his heirs his widow and three minor children, Ida, Iley and S. P. Fant. With the exception of an insurance policy of $5,000 in favor of his heirs, he left no estate.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently June 1958

1 federal appellate ·

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“On the evidence it is entirely certain what part of the purchase-price of the lot described in the pleading and evidence was the money of his wards, and what part was the money of Dr. Fant, the guardian. Under these circumstances, his wards had the right, at their election, to charge their money, with interest, upon the lot, or to take an interest therein proportionate to the amount of their money that went into it, as compared to the purchase-price. They have not the right to elect to take the entire interest in the property, for that would be to appropriate, not their own, but the property of the guardian. Before making their election, the wards are entitled to have accounts stated in both aspects, and, being thus advised, to elect that which is the more beneficial to them.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Bird v. Stein

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1893-10-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Cooper, J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2On the evidence it is entirely certain what part of the purchase-price of the lot desci'ibed in the pleading and evidence was the money of his wards, and what part was the money of Dr. Fant, the guardian. Dnder these circumstances, his wards had the right, at their election, to charge their money, with interest, upon the lot, or to take an interest therein proportionate to the amount of their money that went into it as compared to the purchase-price. They have not the right to elect to take the entire interest in the property, for that would be to appropriate not their own but the property of *580the guardian. Before making their election, the wards are entitled to have accounts stated in both aspects, and, being thus advjsed, to elect that which is the more beneficial to them.

¶3Decree reversed and cause remanded.

/71/miss/576 · .json · Public domain