Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

71 Or. 248

Ward v. Hamlin

Oregon Supreme Court

Decided June 30, 1914

Oregon Supreme Court · decided 1914-06-30

<p>Replevin—Pleading—Complaint.</p> <p>The failure of a complaint to recover personal property to allege that the property was in the eounty when the action was commenced cannot be reached by general demurrer.</p> <p>[As to what are local and transitory actions, see note in 22 Am. St. Rep. 22.]</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently November 1940

2 state decisions

Relies on Marx & Jorgenson v. Croisan

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1914-06-30

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Opinion by

Mr. Chief Justice McBride.

¶2This case is identical with the case of Marx & Jorgenson v. Croisan, 17 Or. 393 (21 Pac. 310), wherein it was held that a like defect in laying the venue could not be reached by a general demurrer. The elaborate *249opinion of Mr. Justice Lord in that case meets every contention urged by the appellant here. Were the matter res integra, a different conclusion might possibly be reached, but, as the rule there deliberately announced seems to dispose of what at best is an unprofitable technicality, we see no reason for departing from it.

¶3The judgment is affirmed. Affirmed.

Mr. Justice Bean and Mr. Justice McNary concur. Mr. Justice Eakin not sitting.
/71/or/248 · .json · Public domain