Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

716 So. 2d 440

716 So.2d 440

98 La.App.5Cir. 149

Ellis v. Binkley

Louisiana Court of Appeal

Decided June 30, 1998

Louisiana Court of Appeal · decided 1998-06-30

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently March 2000

1 state decisions

Relies on 628 So. 2d 1361 - Holmes v. Holmes · 688 So. 2d 75 - Adams v. Marathon Oil Co. · State v. Harris

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1998-06-30

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

liGAUDIN, Judge.

¶1This is an appeal by Stephanie Ellis from a district court judgment which, in part, (1) granted an Exception of No Cause of Action and (2) dismissed a second amended petition asking for punitive damages. We affirm.

¶2Ellis was involved in an accident on October 10, 1991. Her auto collided with a tractor-trailer which was carrying hazardous materials; however, she was neither exposed to any hazardous material nor did the hazardous materials cause or contribute in any way to the accident.

¶3This Court has ruled on this issue in Broussard v. Rogers, 628 So.2d 1361 (La.App. 5 Cir.1993), writs denied at 649 So.2d 378 (La.1995), and Adams v. Marathon Oil Co., 688 So.2d 75 (La.App. 5 Cir.1997). These cases held that punitive or exemplary damages under Louisiana Civil Code art. 2315.3 are not awarded when a plaintiffs injuries are not caused by the hazardous or toxic nature of the substance being transported or handled.

¶4Ellis contends that the tractor-trailer’s driver was not properly rested — he had five hours of sleep prior to the accident — and that this constituted wanton and reckless conduct calling for punitive damages. The trial judge was not impressed with this argument, nor are we.

¶5Following Broussardand Adams, we affirm the judgment dated January 9, 1998 insofar as it pertains to the exception of no cause of action and the second amended petition.

¶6AFFIRMED.

/716/so2d/440 · .json · Public domain