Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

72 Miss. 349

Johnson v. Jennings

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided October 15, 1894

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1894-10-15

From the circuit court of Tallahatchie county. Hon. R. W. Williamson, Judge. Appellee, a merchant, sued appellant for damages for failure to deliver certain cotton seed and for money advanced. A defense relied on was that plaintiff was a public cotton seed buyer and had not paid the privilege tax required by § 3342, code 1892, which makes void all contracts in relation to a business transacted by anyone without having paid the required privilege tax.

Decided 1894-10-15

Woods, J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2By § 3342, code 1892, a privilege tax of ten dollars is levied ‘‘ on each public cotton seed buyer, except merchants in their legitimate business. ’ ’ The appellee was a merchant, and had paid the proper privilege tax on his store. In his legitimate *351business as a merchant, he purchased cotton seed on account from customers to whom he had sold goods as a merchant, and this, we are of opinion, he was entitled to do as an incident to the legitimate prosecution of his mercantile business. That business was the sale or barter of his goods and wares to others. But the evidence clearly shows that the appellee not only bartered goods in his mercantile business for cotton seed, and bought cotton seed on account from customers indebted to his store for goods theretofore sold by him as such merchant, but, also, that he bought seed wherever he could, and sold to fill contracts with others, and to any buyer from him who would pay the best price. 'He bought from the public generally, and he thus purchased to sell again in the best market. He was, in so buying and selling, a public cotton seed buyer, and was not a merchant bartering goods for cotton seed, or buying cotton seed on account from customers indebted to him for goods theretofore bought from his store, as incidental to and proper in the legitimate business of a merchant, as such.

¶3A peremptory charge should have been given for defendant below.

¶4Reversed.

/72/miss/349 · .json · Public domain