Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

72 Or. 220

Davis v. Hall

Oregon Supreme Court

Decided September 8, 1914

Oregon Supreme Court · decided 1914-09-08

<p>Sheriffs and Constables—Liabilities on Bonds—Pleading.</p> <p>1. Where the bond of a constable is conditioned upon Ms faithfully executing and returning all process and paying over according to law all money that shall come into his hands by virtue of his office, there can be no recovery on the bond where it is not alleged that any process was directed or delivered to the constable, or that he had in Ms possession any such a paper, or any money, either officially or privately, or that plaintiff suffered damage because the constable failed to return a writ, if he had one, or that she was a party to or interested in any action in which the process might have been issued.</p> <p>[As to what constitute breaches of bonds of sheriffs and constables, see note in 46 Am. Dec. 509.]</p> <p>Sheriffs and Constables—Liabilities of Bonds—Pleading.</p> <p>2. A complaint alleging that a constable, without exhibiting or serving any process, took chattels from the plaintiff, and, while she was endeavoring to protect her right therein, assaulted and maltreated her, and failed to execute and return the process to him directed in the replevin of the chattels, does not show a liability of the sureties on the constable’s bond conditioned only that he should execute and return all process and pay over according to law all money coming into his hands by virtue of Ms office.</p>

Modified · Decided 1914-09-08

Mr. Justice Burnett

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶21. It is not alleged that any process was directed or delivered to the constable, or that he had in his possession any such a paper or any money either officially or privately. Conceding that he had a writ, it is not apparent how the plaintiff could have suffered damage because the officer did not return it. It is not stated that she was a party to, or in any wise interested in, the action, if any there were, in which such process might have been issued. To recover anything on the bond of the constable the plaintiff must allege and prove a breach of the terms of that instrument, and that she suffered damages on account thereof.

¶32. Further, it is not nominated in the bond that the sureties have underwritten the fisticuffs of their principal, and, as their obligation is strictly construed, there was no cause of action stated against them. It was error to overrule their demurrer to the complaint, or to render any judgment against them. Not so, however, as to the defendant John Hall. Stripped of its verbiage about his official character, the lack of service of process, and the like, which may be rejected as surplusage, there remains in the complaint enough to sustain a civil action for assault and battery, and the consequent judgment.

¶4The judgment is reversed as to the sureties, A. A. Hall and O. E. Hall, and affirmed as to John Hall.

¶5Modified.

Mr. Chief Justice McBride, Mr. Justice Moore and Mr. Justice Ramsey concur.
/72/or/220 · .json · Public domain