Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

73 N.C. 174

Williams v. Hassell

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided June 15, 1875

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1875-06-15

Civil aotioN, for partition, tried before Moore, Jat Spring Term, 1875, MabtiN Superior Court. The following are the facts in the case: Henry Williams died in Martin county in 1860, leaving a will which was duly admitted to probate, and J. R. Stubbs, the executor named therein, qualified and assumed his duties as such.

Decided 1875-06-15

Reade, J.

¶11. Suppose the testator had taken a title to the iand in his lifetime, but left the price unpaid as a debt against his estate; and the executor had paid the debt out of the personal estate, which is primarily the fund for paying debts; that would not have changed the land into personalty. It is the same in this case, where the testator had only contracted for the title. There was error in the ruling of his Honor upon this point.

¶22. His Honor was right in ruling that the children of the testator took only a life estate in the land, (personalty as he considered it,) but he was in error in holding that the children of the children take the remainder. The remainder is “ to the living issue of such child absolutely and forever.” So that they are not the children of the testator’s son Henry that take Henry’s share in remainder ; but only such of his children as may be living at Henry’s death. And so of the rest.

¶33. It will be seen, therefore, that the persons who are to take the remainders are not ascertained. They may be the same who are now in existence, or they may bo added to by subsequent births, or diminished by deaths.

¶4As the persons who may be entitled to the remainder are not ascertained, so they cannot be represented ; and as their numbers and conditions are not known, so the propriety of a sale of the lands cannot be determined.

¶5It was error to order a sale of the land.

¶6This will be certified.

Per Cueiam.

¶7Judgment accordingly.

/73/nc/174 · .json · Public domain