Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

73 N.C. 575

Purvis v. Carstaphan

Supreme Court of North Carolina

Decided June 15, 1875

Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1875-06-15

MotioN to dissolve an Injunction, heard before Moore J, at Spring Term, 1875, Maetin Superior Court. The plaintiffs had executed to the defendant a mortgage, a copy of which is hereto annexed. T-he debts to be secured were those of the husband ; the land mortgaged was the property of the wife.

Decided 1875-06-15

Reade,SJ.

¶1Where a wife joins her husband in a conveyance of her separate property to sedure a debt of the husband, the relation which she sustains to the transaction is that of surety.

¶2A surety is entitled to the benefit of all the securities which the creditor acquires from the principal debtor. And if the creditor prevents or misapplies such securities, to the prejudice of the surety, he thereby discharges the surety, pro tanto.

¶3It follows that if the defendant creditor acquired any security from 'the husband plaintiff, and perverted or misapplied it, either of his own will, or with the concurrence of the principal debtor, it releases the surety wife, pro tanto.

¶4These positions are well supported by the authorities cited in the plaintiff's brief.

¶5It is necessary now to enquire whether the creditor did misapply, to the prejudice of the surety, any security which he had from the principal debtor. And this depends upon the proper construction of the mortgage.

¶6The mortgage recites that the plaintiff husband, desired to engage in farming ; and, to enable him to do so, the defendant had agreed to furnish him with money and supplies to the amount of $1,500, if necessary. And the husband and wife mortgaged not only the crops to be made, but the stock, tools, machines, &c., and the farm itself, which farm was the property of the wife to secure whatever sum the defendant might advance, and to save him harmless, &e. The defendant advanced $1,500 and $1,100 more. And the question is, whether the mortgage covers the $4,100, as well as the $1,500. We think it does not. Although the words “ whatever sum ” and “ save harmless,” are large; yet we think they are restrained by the sum specified, $1,500. The stipulation was, that the *582defendant was to furnish $1,500, “ if necessaryIf so large a sum was not necessary, then “ whatever sum ” might be necessary, less than that.

¶7It is admitted that the creditor received from the debtor husband more of the crop, &c., produced on the farm than was necessary to pay oif the $1,500; but by the consent of the husband, he applied it to the excess over the $1,500. While this appropriation was good as against the husband, yet as against the surety wife, it was a perversion, and operated as a discharge ot the liability of her land.

¶8There was error in dissolving the injunction.

¶9Let this be certified.

Pee Cueiam;.

¶10Judgment accordingly.

/73/nc/575 · .json · Public domain