Fletcher v. United States’s Empirical Analysis
730 F.3d 1206 · 2013
Citation profile
3 federal appellate ·
Relationships
Applies 25 U.S.C. § 162A · 25 U.S.C. § 4011 · 25 U.S.C. § 4041 · 25 U.S.C. § 4044 · 5 U.S.C. § 702
Relies on Hecht Co. v. Bowles · Trw Inc v. Adelaide Andrews · Astoria Federal Savings & Loan Ass'n v. Solimino · County of Oneida New York v. Oneida Indian Nation of New York State New York · Bryan v. Itasca County
Most-quoted passages
The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 6 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.
“The government recognizes that the 1906 Act creates a trust relationship running directly between the government and individual Osage headright owners, but it suggests one of the usual fiduciary duties attendant to a typical trust relationship' here belongs only to someone else (the tribe). Of course, it’s not impossible Congress could have chosen to rearrange normal trust principles in this way, but the government identifies nothing in the text or structure of the relevant laws suggesting such a de sign. To the contrary, § 4011(a) indicates that the government’s accounting duty applies to all funds “held in trust ... for the benefit of an Indian tribe or an individual Indian.” In turn, the 1906 Act requires the Secretary to hold Osage mineral wealth in trust for individual Osage headright owners. Taken together, these provisions suggest a trust relationship and an attendant accounting duty running directly between the government and individual Osage headright owners like the plaintiffs before us.- We cannot detect so much as a whiff suggesting they grant accounting privileges only to the tribe.... [E]ven if we could somehow conjure up the sort of ambiguity the government seems to assume but never identifies, it would still have to be resolved in the plaintiffs’ favor.”
1 later decision quote this exact passage · from the majority“By its plain language [§ 4011(a)] appears to impose on the federal government a duty to “account for” — to render a reckoning, answer for, explain or justify, see 1 The Oxford English Dictionary 85 (2d ed.1989) — the daily and annual balances of money it holds in trust. Of course, the government must account, answer or explain itself to someone, and the plain language of the statute seems to tell us who: to the tribe when the funds are held “for [its] benefit,” and to individual tribal members when the funds are held “for [their] benefit.” As we’ve seen, the trust funds at issue in this case — collected and disbursed under the terms of the 1906 Act — are being held for the benefit of individual members of the Osage Nation. So it would seem that — in our case at least — Congress has chosen to afford individual tribal members the statutory right to seek and obtain an accounting, just as plaintiffs contend.”
1 later decision quote this exact passage · from the majority“Under the district court’s reading, the government’s accounting obligations extend only to trust fund deposits but not withdrawals. The Secretary has to account to headright owners for what goes into their trust fund, but not what comes out. But what could possibly be the point of that? Half of an accounting may be closer to no accounting at all — an assurance deposits are properly handled seems pretty nearly pointless without a corresponding assurance disbursements are too....We can well imagine Congress choosing either to grant or deny the right to request an accounting, but no one has advanced any reason why it might adopt an almost useless halfway measure for tribes and individual tribal members alike.”
1 later decision quote this exact passage · from the majority
How this case has been treated — in progress
Whether each later court followed, distinguished, criticized, or overruled this decision. The treatment classification (task #35) runs highest-cited cases first and lights up here as it reaches this one.