Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

74 N.H. 48

65 A 254

Beckman v. Hampton

Supreme Court of New Hampshire

Decided November 7, 1906

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · decided 1906-11-07

Trespass, for breaking and entering tbe plaintiff’s close and destroying his buildings. Plea of soil and freehold as to the portion of the locus described as White’s Rocks, and the general issue as to* the remainder. Trial by jury. Verdict for the plaintiff as to that: part of the locus described in the plea of soil and freehold, and not. guilty as to the remainder.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently June 1959

1 state decisions

Relies on Marsh v. Concord Mutual Fire Insurance · Wait v. Nashua Armory Ass'n · State v. Saidell

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1906-11-07

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Bingham, J.

¶1 The contention of the defendants is that the remarks of counsel for the plaintiff in his closing argument were not warranted by the evidence and were prejudicial. If the remarks complained of contained statements of fact not supported by the evidence, they were not relevant to any issue of fact tried in the case nor of a character to prejudice the jury against the defendants. In fact, they had no bearing upon the case except so far as they tended to support the conclusions of law sought to be drawn by the plaintiff’s counsel, that the lands embraced within the limits of the town of Hampton belonged to the proprietors and their heirs and not to the municipality. But the court declined to charge the jury in accordance with this view of the law, and charged them that lands within the town of Hampton which had not been granted to individuals belonged to the town as against everybody, except those who could show a better title. The remarks not being prejudicial, the error was harmless. Verdicts are not set aside under such circumstances. Wait v. Association, 66 N. H. 581; Sabine v. Merrill, 67 N. H. 226; State v. Saidell, 70 N. H. 174; Marsh v. Insurance Co., 71 N. H. 253, 256; Leavitt v. Company, 72 N. H. 290; Parsons v. Wentworth, 73 N. H. 122.

¶2 Exception overruled.

All concurred.
/74/nh/48 · .json · Public domain