Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

75 Ark. 37

Owens v. Gunther

Supreme Court of Arkansas

Decided April 8, 1905

Supreme Court of Arkansas · decided 1905-04-08

Jesse C. Hart, Chancellor. STATEMENT BY THE COURT. Mary Ellen Owens, Catherine M.- Owens and Margaret Owens were the owners of three lots in the city of Eittle Rock, worth about $8,000. Their father, E. J. Owens, also claimed to own a life estate in these lots as tenant by curtesy. He was guardian of his children named above, and had secured an order of the probate court authorizing him to mortgage the lots for the sum of $3,000 for the purpose of educating his wards.

Relies on Jones v. Yore · Munson v. Washband · Barker v. Hibbard

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Judgment modified · Decided 1905-04-08

How this case has been cited

Cited by 16 later decisions — most recently April 2002

16 state decisions

4019051910192019301940195019601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Riddick, J.,

¶1(after stating the facts.) This is an appeal from a judgment allowing attorney’s fees against the two minors, appellants, and directing that the amount allowed be a lien on the lots which were involved in the litigation in which the services were performed for which pay is claimed. Counsel for appellants say that they make no contention that the services were not well performed, or that such services did not result in great benefit to the estate of the minors.- And the question presented is whether the minors are liable for such charge, and whether'it can be enforced against their estate.

¶2Now, it seems to be fairly well settled that where an infant has no guardian, his; estate may be made liable for a reasonable attorney’s fee, i-f the services rendered were for the manifest benefit of the infant, and necessary for the protection of valuable rights belonging to him.) Epperson v. Nugent, 57 Miss. 45; Baker v. Hibbard, 54 N. H. 539; Munson v. Washband, 31 Conn. 303; Jones v. Yore, 142 Mo. 38; Rodgers, Domestic Relations, § 677.

¶3This case seems to rest on the same principle; for, though the infants here had a statutory guardian, this guardian himself claimed an interest in their property as tenant by curtesy, and his interests were so antagonistic to the interests of his wards that the chancery court refused to allow him to defend for them, and appointed a guardian ad litem to make their defense. These petitioners appeared for the guardian ad litem, and conducted the litigation for the infants to a successful conclusion. As the relation of the statutory guardian of the infants to the property in litigation was such that he could not represent the interests of his wards, they were in the same position, so far as this case was concerned, as if they had no regular guardian; and we think that under the admitted facts they are liable for a reasonable-attorney’s fee. To that extent we think that the judgment was correct, but we do not see' on what grounds the court declared the amount allowed to be a lien on the lots. We think in that respect the decree should be modified, and in all other respects affirmed.

¶4It is so ordered.

/75/ark/37 · .json · Public domain