Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

75 Kan. 848

Weishaar v. Haenky

Supreme Court of Kansas

Decided May 11, 1907

Supreme Court of Kansas · decided 1907-05-11

<p>PRACTICE, District Court — Cause Remanded — Motion for Judgment. It was said the district court had jurisdiction, after the mandate of this court reversing the judgment of the trial court was brought to its attention by a motion for judgment, to allow or deny the motion.</p>

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently December 1916

2 state decisions

Relies on Clevenger v. Figley

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Remanded for correction and affirmed · Decided 1907-05-11

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam:

¶1When the record containing the mandate of this court reversing the judgment of the district court a second time for want of sufficient facts was brought to its attention by a motion for judgment a judicial question was presented which the court *849had jurisdiction to decide. It had the same jurisdiction to allow that it had to deny the motion. Even if it decided wrong, that fact did not oust it of jurisdiction. (See Clevenger v. Figley, 68 Kan. 699, 75 Pac. 1001.)

¶2Proceedings in error to review the judgment rendered not having been commenced in time, this court cannot interfere.

¶3The only other meritorious question is that the Weishaars should have the benefit of the subrogation stipulation signed by the Haenkys. It might perhaps require some finesse to bring the omission under the exceptions taken to the referee’s report, but it does not appear to be indispensably necessary that this should be done. The stipulation removed the subject covered by it from further controversy. The matter was no longer one for which the Weishaars were required to contend, and the failure to frame the judgment on the basis of the stipulation may be regarded as a matter of oversight, rather than of error, to be corrected, as a matter of course. If it were an ordinary case of failure to request a finding upon a pertinent litigated fact the court would adhere to its rule.

¶4The case is remanded that the judgment may be corrected according to stipulation, and as corrected the judgment of the district court is affirmed.

/75/kan/848 · .json · Public domain