Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

75 Minn. 248

Mather v. Curley

Supreme Court of Minnesota

Decided January 11, 1899

Supreme Court of Minnesota · decided 1899-01-11

<p>Tax Sale — Defective Notice of Expiration of Time for Redemption.</p> <p>A notice of expiration of redemption from a tax sale stated “that the time allowed by law for redemption from said sale will have expired after sixty days have elapsed after service of this notice has been made, and proof thereof, and of the sheriff’s fees, has been filed in this [the county auditor’s] office.” Held, the notice does not comply with G. S. 1894, § 1654, and is void.</p>

Relies on State ex rel. Kipp v. Nord · Peterson v. P. P. Mast & Co.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1899-01-11

How this case has been cited

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently June 1945

5 state decisions

30189919001910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

CANTY, J.

¶1This is an action to determine adverse claims to real estate. The trial court found for defendant, and plaintiff appeals from an order denying a new trial.

¶2The notice of expiration of redemption from the tax sale stated,

“That the time allowed by law for redemption from said sale will have expired after sixty days have elapsed after service of this notice has been made, and proof thereof, and of the sheriff’s fees, has been filed in this [the county auditor’s] office.”

¶3Respondent contends that this notice is void because it does not state when the time to redeem will expire, and, in our opinion, the point is well taken. The notice does not state that the time to redeem will expire at the end of the 60 days, but that it will have expired after the 60 days; that is, it will have expired some time after the end of the 60 days, but whether it is one day or one month or one year after, is not stated.

¶4In State v. Nord, 73 Minn. 1, 75 N. W. 760, we held that a notice which states a longer time than the statutory period is void, as well as one which states a shorter time. See Peterson v. P. P. Mast & Co., 61 Minn. 118, 63 N. W. 168. But it seems to us that no *249time at all is stated in this notice. It amounts to a statement that the time to redeem will not expire for at least 60 days. Then we are of the opinion that the notice is void.

¶5It is true, as claimed by appellant, that the court below did not dispose of the case on this point. But it is, in our opinion, the most clear and satisfactory point on which to dispose of it. It was not, as appellant contends, necessary for defendant to appeal in order to raise this point. He is entitled to raise any point which shows conclusively that, on the findings of fact, he is entitled to judgment.

¶6Order affirmed.

/75/minn/248 · .json · Public domain