Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

75 Miss. 349

State v. Buchanan

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided December 15, 1897

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1897-12-15

Feom the circuit court, second district, Chickasaw county. HoN. Newman Cayoe, Judge. The facts are stated in the opinion. We are aware that it is held in many cases that the specific crime intended to be committed must be named, but we do not think this court will consider it necessary to set out the crime, when it is charged by the grand jury that the crime intended to have been committed was to said grand jurors unknown.

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“is left to grope in the dark as to what crime the state may offer evidence to show he intended to commit.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including 962 So. 2d 1237 - Quang Thanh Tran v. State

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1897-12-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 15 later decisions — most recently February 2013

1 federal appellate · 13 state decisions

401897190019101920193019401950196019701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Woods, C. J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2The indictment charges the appellee with the burglarious breaking and entering of the dwelling house of one T. S. Johnson, “with the wilful, felonious and burglarious intent then and there to commit some crime to the jurors aforesaid unknown.” To this indictment the defendant demurred, assigning, amongst other causes of demurrer, that it charges no crime under the laws of this state; and that it fails to charge the specific crime with intent to commit which the defendant was alleged to have broken and entered the house. The demurrer was by the court below sustained, and from -this action of that court the state appeals, and assigns the same for error.

¶3The crime of burglary consists of two essential elements, viz.: (1) The burglarious breaking and entering of the house, and (2) the felonious intent to commit some crime therein. Both elements must be laid in the indictment, and both must be proved as laid. This is familiar learning, and is not contro*351verted by the attorney-general. His contention is that the charge in the indictment of an intent to commit some crime in the house burglariously broken and entered, is sufficiently specific, and that an intent to commit a named particular felony is unnecessary. But this is unsound, because this general and indefinite averment of an intent to commit some crime, does not advise the accused of the nature and character of the crime, or one of the essential ingredients of the crime, preferred against him. He is left to grope in the dark as to what crime the state may offer evidence to show he intended to commit. Under this very indefinite charge, the prosecution may compel the prisoner to run the gauntlet of all the felonies of the criminal calendar, and rain upon his defenceless head blows from every quarter, in common fairness, every defendant charged with a high crime is entitled to know specifically and particularly what felony is laid to his charge. In this case, the charge preferred was that the accused intended “to commit some crime. ’ ’ What crime ? Larceny ? Nape ? Murder ? Arson ? Poisoning ? How could the prisoner answer ? Or how come prepared to defend? And how could he plead judgment of the court on this vague and indefinite charge to another prosecution for any one of the particular crimes which might have been embraced in this general charge ?

¶4That the indictment is fatally defective cannot be doubted in the light of authority. See Wharton’s Cr. Law, sec. 1614; Bishop’s Cr. Proc., vol. 2, sec. 142; Arch. Cr. Pl. & Prac., Pomeroy’s notes, p. 1102; People v. Nelson, 58 Cal., 104; State v. Lockhart, 24 Ga., 420; Portwood v. State, 29 Texas, 47.

¶5Affirmed.

/75/miss/349 · .json · Public domain