Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

750 P.2d 546

72 UtahAdv.Rep. 6

State v. Tillman

Utah Supreme Court

Decided December 22, 1987

Utah Supreme Court · decided 1987-12-22

Relies on People v. . Sullivan · State v. Russell · State v. Richmond

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1987-12-22

How this case has been cited

Cited by 144 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently July 2024 · most notably Schad v. Arizona (1991), State v. Carter (1989)

2 federal appellate · 1 district · 135 state decisions

60019871990200020102020decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

HOWE, Justice:

¶1(concurring in the result).

¶2I concur except I concur only in the result of parts VII and VIII.

¶3I concur in the result of Part VII on the basis of the analysis of the unanimity rule in State v. Russell, 733 P.2d 162 (Utah 1987). Although the instant case does not involve the defendant’s mens rea as in State v. Russell, in that case we approved the rule of People v. Sullivan, 173 N.Y. 122, 65 N.E. 989 (1903), which held that the jury does not have to be unanimous on the precise manner in which the crime was committed, or by which of several alternative methods or modes, or under which interpretation of the evidence so long as there is substantial evidence to support each of the methods, modes, or manners charged. I cannot accept the implication in the majority opinion that had the defendant requested separate verdict forms requiring the jury to be unanimous as to what felony he was in the course of committing when the homicide took place, he would have been entitled to such a verdict. State v. Russell, supra,held that the defendant was not entitled to have the jury instructed that they must be unanimous as to the defendant’s mens rea. That holding likewise applies here where we are concerned with the manner in which the killing occurred.

¶4*583As to Part VIII, I base my concurrence on State v. Johnson, 740 P.2d 1264 (Utah 1987), where we employed the res gestae analysis which we adopted in State v. Weddle, 29 Utah 2d 464, 511 P.2d 733 (1973). Under that analysis, it is sufficient if the killing is directly associated with the felony as part of one continuous, interrelated occurrence. See the cases cited and discussed in State v. Johnson, supra, State v. Dudrey, 30 Wash.App. 447, 635 P.2d 750 (1981), and State v. Richmond, 112 Ariz. 228, 540 P.2d 700 (1975). The same reasoning applies to the arson which immediately followed the attack on the victim.

/750/p2d/546 · .json · Public domain