Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

76 Ala. 489

McIlwain v. Vaughan

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided December 15, 1884

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1884-12-15

Tried before the Hon. Jon. Haralson. This action was brought by Cyrus Yanghan and Matilda, his wife, against S. P. Mcllwain, to recover damages for the conversion of two mules, named Jane and Woolly \ and. was commenced on the 3d April, 1883.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently November 1889

3 state decisions

Relies on Pickens v. Oliver · McCall v. Jones

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1884-12-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

SOMERNILLE, J.

¶1— The property, for the conversion of which the present suit is brought, is shown to have been the equitable separate estate of the wife, created by a direct gift made to her by her husband, and reduced to possession. The suit should, therefore, have been brought in the name of the husband alone, as trustee, and uot in the names of the husband and wife jointly. The improper joinder of the wife, as one of the co-plaintiffs, presents a case of variance between the allegata and probata, which necessitates a reversal of the cause. — McCall v. Jones, 72 Ala. 368; Dickens v. Oliver, 29 Ala. 528.

¶2"We have examined the rulings of the court, and find no other reversible error in the record. The cause will be remanded, in order that the plaintiffs may amend the pleadings, so as to obviate this variance, if desired.

¶3Reversed and remanded.

/76/ala/489 · .json · Public domain