Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

76 Vt. 174

Brunnell v. Carr

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided January 7, 1904

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1904-01-07

Case Eor Deceit in the sale of land. Plea, the general ■issue. Trial by court in the city court of the city of Montpelier, Laird, Acting Judge. Judgment for the defendants to recover their costs. Held: as matter of law, that by the terms of ■said deed the plaintiffs assumed and agreed to- ]Say the mortgage which said Parker held upon the real estate, and rendered judgment for the defendants to recover their costs.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently March 1936

2 state decisions

Relies on Woodward & Perkins v. Barnes · Russell v. Phelps

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1904-01-07

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Rowell, C. J.

¶1This is case for deceit in the sale of land conveyed to the plaintiffs by the joint deed of the defendants. The deceit consisted in a statement in the deed that the premises were free from incumbrance, except a certain mortgage whereon was then due $640, which the grantees assumed and .agreed to pay as a part of the price, whereas there was more then due thereon, to the knowledge of the defendants, which the plaintiffs had to pay.

¶2It not appearing that the land was Mrs. Carr’s, the case does not come within the Married Women’s Act, but must stand upon the common law, and at the common law a married woman is not liable for torts based upon her contracts, Tut only for her torts simpliciter. Woodward v. Barnes, 46 Vt. 332; Russell v. Phelps, 73 Vt. 390, 50 Atl. 1101.

¶3But Mr. Carr is liable for his tort in the matter, and •should pay to the plaintiffs $167.70, the amount they had to pay by reason thereof, with interest thereon by way of damages from the commencement of the suit, the record not showing when the payment was made.

¶4Judgment affirmed as to Mrs. Carr, but reverseId as to Mr. Carr, and judgment against him for said last-mentioned *176sum, zvith interest thereon as aforesaid, and costs. Certided execution ■granted.

/76/vt/174 · .json · Public domain