Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

77 Ky. 171

Anderson v. Commonwealth

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided September 11, 1878

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1878-09-11

Case 4 — INDICTMENT APPEAL FROM M’LEAN CRIMINAL COURT. 1. While it would seem, from section 347 of the Criminal Code, that this court has no jurisdiction of this appeal, Commonwealth v. Davis, 12 Bush, 240, settles the question that it has jurisdiction.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently September 1909

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1878-09-11

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

JUDGE ELLIOTT

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2This indictment charges the appellant with having given and sold spirituous liquors to Peter Belt, an infant, and not the child of appellant, without the written consent of the father or guardian of the infant.

¶3On the trial the appellant was found guilty and judgment rendered against him for $50, and the first question to be considered is, has this court jurisdiction of this case on appeal. By section 347 of the Criminal Code of 1877 it is provided that “the Court of Appeals shall have appellate jurisdiction in penal actions and prosecutions for misdemeanors in the following cases only, viz. If the judgment be for a fine of $50, or for imprisonment exceeding thirty days, or if the judgment be for the defendant in cases in which a fine exceeding $50, or confinement exceeding thirty days, might have been inflicted.”

¶4*172As this is the last legislative act defining this court’s jurisdiction in penal cases, it amounts to a revocation of the previous legislation on the subject, and as the fine assessed in this case did not exceed $50, this court has no jurisdiction of this case on appeal.

¶5It is, however, stated by appellant’s counsel that in the case of the Commonwealth v. Davis this court, ruled.in favor of jurisdiction in a similar case. (See 12 Bush, 240.) It will be seen by an examination of that case that it was decided at the-September Term of this court, 1876, which was before the Code of 1877 went into effect, and under the laws then in force this court had jurisdiction in. such cases.

¶6Wherefore the appeal in this case is dismissed.

/77/ky/171 · .json · Public domain