Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

77 Mass. 327

Commonwealth v. Hildreth

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 15, 1858

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1858-10-15

<p>On the trial of an indictment for being a common seller of intoxicating liquors, the Commonwealth, after introducing evidence of sales in a certain house, and for the purpose of proving that the defendant owned or occupied the house, may give in evidence his statements a year before the time covered by the indictment, that he was repairing the house, and it would cost him as much as to build a new one.</p> <p>Upon a trial for being a common seller of intoxicating liquors from August 1st to December 1st 1857, a newspaper published in January 1858, containing an article purporting to be signed by the defendant, speaking of his keeping a certain public house and selling liquor, there, was admitted in evidence, after the introduction of evidence of sales of liquor in that house, and of the defendant’s speaking to the editor of the newspaper about publishing a series of such articles, but without proof that he wrote the article or handed the manuscript of it to the editor. SeZcZ, that the article was rightly admitted in evidence: and that whether it was in the defendant’s handwriting was immaterial, if he afterwards ratified it.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently February 1908

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1858-10-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court.

¶11. The statement of' the defendant that he was repairing the house, in which there was evidence that liquor had been sold, had some tendency to prove that he was the owner and occupant of the house, and was rightly admitted for that purpose.

¶22. The article published in the Natick Observer was sufficiently identified to be competent evidence for the same purpose, and its effect and weight were for the jury. It bore the signature of the defendant and purported to be written by him. But it is immaterial whether he wrote it or not. It is enough if he *330recognized or sanctioned it. The evidence that it was not in his handwriting was rightly rejected as immaterial.

¶33. The instruction that if the defendant ratified the article after it was written, the jury would regard it as his, was right. If he recognized the article as his, or made it his own, or referred to it as expressing his views, it was enough.

¶44. The article published on the 2d of January 1858 spoke of keeping the house at a period then passed, and was rightly admitted in support of the charge of selling liquors since the 1st of August previous. Exceptions overruled.

/77/mass/327 · .json · Public domain