Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

78 Ark. 137

Main v. Jarrett

Supreme Court of Arkansas

Decided March 3, 1906

Supreme Court of Arkansas · decided 1906-03-03

<p>Sale — shipment—delivery of bill of lading. — Where, in an action to recover the purchase price of goods sold and delivered to a carrier to be transported to defendant, the defense was that only a part of the goods was delivered, it was error to instruct the jury that the plaintiffs could not recover unless they furnished defendants a bill of lading showing that the goods were delivered to the carrier, if the non-delivery of the bill of lading was hot pleaded as a defense.</p>

reversed · Decided 1906-03-03

Battle, J.

¶1The trial court erred in instructing the jury. The instructions made the right of plaintiffs to recover to depend upon the delivery by them to the defendants of a bill of lading, when the non-delivery of a bill of lading was not pleaded as a defense. No such issue was joined. The undisputed evidence shows that a bill of lading was sent by mail to the defendants. But they say they never received it,.and that they did not inform plaintiffs that they had not received it and made no request for a duplicate. They received all the goods purchased, except a show case, and for that reason refused to pay for the goods. The instructions were, therefore, erroneous.

¶2Reversed and remand for a new trial.

/78/ark/137 · .json · Public domain