Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

78 N.M. 188

429 P.2d 647

Bouldin v. Bruce M. Bernard, Inc.

New Mexico Supreme Court

Decided July 10, 1967

New Mexico Supreme Court · decided 1967-07-10

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“* * * [A]n oral ruling by the trial judge is not a final judgment. It is merely evidence of what the court had decided to do—a decision that the trial court can change at any time before the entry of a final judgment.”

quoted by 2 later decisions, including In Re Estate of Harrington, Peterson Properties, Del Rio Plaza Shopping Center v. Valencia County Valuation Protests Board

“It has long been the rule that, absent an express statute or rule, an appeal will not lie from anything other than a formal written order or judgment, signed by the judge and filed in the record in the case ____ final judgment in a criminal case either adjudicates the defendant guilty and imposes, suspends, or defers sentence or dismisses the charges.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including State v. Lohberger

Relies on State v. Morris · Curbello v. Vaughn · State Ex Rel. Reynolds v. McLean

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1967-07-10

How this case has been cited

Cited by 40 later decisions — most recently December 2023 · most notably State v. Kenneman (1982), High Ridge Hinkle Joint Venture v. City of Albuquerque (1994)

40 state decisions

1001967197019801990200020102020decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1 OPINION

HENSLEY, Jr., Chief Judge, Court of Appeals.

¶2 The threshold question is one of jurisdiction.

¶3 The defendants filed a motion to dismiss the plaintiffs’ complaint. The motion was argued on June 27, 1966, and at the conclusion of the hearing the trial court announced to counsel that the motion would be sustained. On July 1, 1966, the plaintiffs filed notice of appeal. The transcript of record was filed in this Court on September 2, 1966. Thereafter, it was discovered that no written order sustaining the motion to dismiss had ever been entered. An order was prepared, signed by the trial judge, and filed with the clerk of the trial court on October 5, 1966. Certiorari for diminution of the record caused the order to be added to the transcript of the record here. No other notice of appeal has been filed.

¶4 Section 21-2-1(5) (1), N.M.S.A. 1953, also appearing as Rule 5, subd. 1, of the Supreme Court Rules, provides for appeals within thirty (30) days from the entry of any final judgment. This statute has been construed in Curbello v. Vaughn, 76 N.M. 687, 417 P.2d 881; State ex rel. Reynolds v. McLean, 74 N.M. 178, 392 P.2d 12; State v. Morris, 69 N.M. 89, 364 P.2d 348. In each case we held that appeals will lie only from a formal written order or judgment signed by the judge and filed in the case, or entered upon the records of the court and signed by the judge thereof. In the hope that the likelihood of a recurrence of this regrettable situation will be minimized, we would here again repeat, that an oral ruling by the trial judge is not a final judgment. It is merely evidence of what the court had decided to do — a decision that the trial court can change at any time before the entry of a final judgment.

¶5 The notice of appeal was prematurely filed and it was a nullity. The subsequent entry of a final order does not activate the notice of appeal so as to constitute compliance with § 21-2-1(5) (1), supra. See 3A Barron and Holtzoff, Federal Practice and Procedure (Rules ed.) § 1553.

¶6 The appeal must be dismissed. It is so ordered.

CHAVEZ, C. J., and NOBLE, MOISE and COMPTON, JJ., concur.
/78/nm/188 · .json · Public domain