Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

79 N.H. 215

107 A 625

Roberts v. Corson

Supreme Court of New Hampshire

Decided May 6, 1919

Supreme Court of New Hampshire · decided 1919-05-06

Bill in Equity. The plaintiffs are the heirs at law of Lewis W. Tebbetts. The defendants are the residuary legatee named in the will, the executor of the will and others. The executor asks the advice of the court as to who is entitled to the property passing under the residuary clause of the will.

Relies on Glover v. Baker · Hoeffer v. Clogan · Chapin v. School District Number Two in Winchester

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1919-05-06

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently March 1962

10 state decisions

50191919201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Young, J.

¶1 If the words of the residuary clause are given their ordinary meaning the testator intended to create a trust for the benefit of those who are or who may become members of Humane Lodge; that is, he intended to create a trust for the benefit of a definite section of the public. A gift of this kind constitutes what is commonly known as a charitable or public trust. Glover v. Baker, 76 N. H. 393, 417; Haynes v. Carr, 70 N. H. 463, 482; Jackson v. Philips, 14 Allen, 539; Hoeffer v. Clogan, 171 Ill. 462; s. c. 63 Am. St. Rep. 241, note 249; 11 C. J. 301.

¶2 If the purpose such a trust is intended to effectuate is legal and the persons for whose benefit it is established can be ascertained, it is the duty of the court to enforce it. Fernald v. First Church of Christ Scientist, 77 N. H. 108; French v. Lawrence, 76 N. H. 234; Adams v. Page, 76 N. H. 96. It is immaterial in so far as the validity of such a bequest is concerned how large or how small a section of the public it is intended to benefit. That, is, whether it is intended to benefit every living human being, Glover v. Baker, 76 N. H. 393, 417; or whether its scope is limited to the poor and needy of New Hampshire, Haynes v. Carr, 70 N. H. 463; the, sick of Franklin and vicinity, Adams v. Page, 76 N. H. 96; or to indigent and distressed masons of Bible Lodge society in Goffstown, their widows and orphans, Duke v. Fuller, 9 N. H. 536. The bequest in question, therefore, constitutes a valid public trust for the purpose for which it was created, is legal, and it is possible to ascertain those it is intended to benefit. The person who establishes such a trust may entrust its administration to a corporation, Chapin v. Winchester School District, 35 N. H. 445; to a voluntary association, Parker v. Cowell, 16 N. H. 149; 11 C. J. 339; or to trustees appointed by the probate court P. S., c. 198; Petition of Straw, 78 N. H. 506. It will be unnecessary therefore to consider whether Humane Lodge is a corporation or a voluntary association. In either case it will be the duty of the executor to turn over the property passing under the residuary clause to the lodge unless the court finds that administering the trust is inconsistent with the purpose for which the lodge was established. If that is found, the executor will turn the property over to whomever the probate court appoints to administer the trust.

¶3 Case discharged.

All concurred.
/79/nh/215 · .json · Public domain