Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 I. & N. Dec. 460

M-S-H

Board of Immigration Appeals

Decided July 1, 1960

Board of Immigration Appeals · decided 1960-07-01

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently July 1975

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1960-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

                      MATTER OF M S

                  In VISA PETITION Proceedings
                                SPM–N-30
             Decided by Regional Commissioner October 19, 1959
           Approved by Assistant Commissioner February 19, 1960

Nonimmigrant—Section 101(a)(15)(H)(i), 1952 act—Position of intern not
 temporary.
Permanent nature of position of intern in hospital precludes granting Intended alien employee nonimmigrant status under section 101(a) (15) (El)
   (i) of the 1952 act notwithstanding that alien's services are limited to
  period of one year.

               BEFORE THE REGI"NAL COMMISSIONER

   Discussion: The petitioner desires the services of the two beneficiaries, Drs. V—L P and A—M— P—, as interns
for a period of one year. The Assistant Administrator of the petitioning hospital states that it is proposed that the benefic i aries be
paid $150.00 a month, plus rooms, meals, and uniforms.
   The beneficiaries are both medical doctors born in the Philippines
in 1927 and 1928, respectively. The district director denied the
petition on the ground that it had not been established that the
beneficiaries are bona fide nonimmigrants nor that the positions
sought to be filled are temporary.
   On August 31, 1959, the District Director at St. Paul approved
petitions filed by M S II in Minneapolis, Minnesota,
granting the beneficiaries of the petition now under consideration
first preference quota status Li) conic to the United Statea as immigrants. In submitting the present petition the petitioner's counsel
stated: "Due to the fact that the first preference of the Philippine
quota is closed and it will be some time before a number would be
available to the beneficiaries, I am submitting herewith Form
I-129B in duplicate duly executed by the Hospital in order that
they be permitted to come to the United States to work at the
Hospital since their services are urgently needed."
  It is reasonable to assume that had the petitioner desired the
beneficiaries' services to fill temporary positions     for a temporary

                                   460
   ieriod the original petition would have been filed under sections
   i01 (a) (15) (H) (i) and 214(c) of the Immigration and Nationality
   !let rather than under sections 203(a) (1) (A) and 204(b) of the act.
     The petitioner's counsel states that "The situation of an intern
  is of necessity a temporary one since, after a period of internship,
  they are no longer interns but must graduate into the position of
 Residents following a program of residence." This is unquestionably true insofar as a particular intern is concerned. However,
 when an intern completes his internship and moves into a residency
 or private practice, the work he did as an intern must still be done
 by someone. In this sense the position is of a permanent rather
 than a temporary nature.
     To be eligible for admission as a nonimmigrant under section
 101(a) (15(H) (i) the beneficiary must have a residence in a foreign
 country which he has no intention of abandoning and the work
 which he is coming to the United States to perform must be of a
 temporary nature as distinguished from work of a continuing or
 permanent character.
     Prior to the present act, section 3(2) of the Immigration Act of
 1924 provided for nonimmigrant status for aliens visiting the United
 States temporarily for business or pleasure. In construing this
 section with respect to the word "temporary," it was stated in
 Matter of L  —     , 
3 I. & N. Dec. 857
 (B.I.A., 1950), as follows:
  As we see the problem, the standard to be applied Is not the expectancy of
the appellant's employment because of the seniority rule or the terminology
used to describe his employment, but rather whether the work to be performed by the appellant in the United States is considered to be of a permanent duration at a fixed place of employment.
   When the present law was under consideration by Congress it was
pointed out that the provision for the admission of temporary
visitors is substantially the same as in the 1924 act (Senate Report
No. 1137, 82d Cong., 2d Sess., p. 19 (1952), House Report No. 1365,
82d Cong., 2d Sess., p. 43 (1952), Senate Report No. 1515, 81st
Cong., 2d Sess., p. 525 (1950)).
  In deciding Natter of           
6 I. & N. Dec. 533
, March 8, 1955,
the Board of Immigration Appeals said :
  The definition in the present act as to a temporary visitor for business or
pleasure differs but very little from the definition contained in section 3(2)
of the prior Immigration Act of 1924 which stated that when used In that
act the term "immigrant" meant any alien departing from any place outside
the United States destined for the United States except an alien visiting the
United Slates temporarily as a tourist or temporarily for business or pleasure. … The business for which the alien is coming must be temporary
and not continuing or permanent in character; not only the visit but the,business must be of a temporary character. … [Matter of C—, 56172/725;
Matter of R—    v       55077/752, June 20, 1938. (Emphasis supplied.)]

                                    461
   The proposed employment for only one year does not change the
character of the position from permanent to temporary.
   From the foregoing it is concluded that the petition cannot be
approved. The action of the district director in denying the petition was proper. Accordingly, the appeal must be dismissed.
  Order: It is ordered that the appeal be dismissed.




                                462

/8/indec/460 · .json · Public domain