Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 Miss. 670

Harrison v. Breeden

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1843

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1843-01-15

IN ERROR from the circuit court of the county of Adams. This was a proceeding, by petition, in'the circuit court, to enforce a mechanic’s lien, where the contract had not been reduced to writing.

Decided 1843-01-15

Per Curiam.

¶1.This case involves the construction of the law in regard to the lien of mechanics, and all the questions involved in the record have been determined at the present term of this court, in the case of Richardson v. Warwick & Ray. See ante, page 131.

¶2It is insisted, in this case, that the lien can only attach when the contract for the work or materials has been reduced to writing. The contract, in the case just cited, was a verbal one; and, although the point was not made, it was the subject of consideration.

¶3The statute does not, in express terms, require the contract to be written; and there is no reason why we should insert a condition. If it be not reduced to writing, it cannot be recorded; and one of the modes of preserving the lien cannot be resorted to, yet the other mode of retaining it, by bringing suit, may be adopted. Writing is rarely, if ever, necessary to the validity of a contract, unless by virtue of.some statutory provision.

¶4The other objections urged in this'cause were expressly considered and overruled in the case above cited.

¶5The judgment will be affirmed.

/8/miss/670 · .json · Public domain