Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 N.H. 389

Sibley v. McAllaster

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided December 15, 1836

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1836-12-15

This was an action of assumpsit, for $750 money paid, laid out and expended. The cause was tried at February term, 1835, on the general issue, and a verdict taken, by consent, for the plaintiff, subject to the opinion of the court upon the following case. Ebenezer Lerned, the defendant’s testator, on the 25th July, 1827, gave to the Hopkinton Academy his note of hand for $500, which was signed by the plaintiff as Lern-ed ⅛ surety.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1836-12-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 17 later decisions — most recently May 1917

17 state decisions

40183618401850186018701880189019001910decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Richardson, C. J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2Conceding, for the present, that the note not having been presented to the executor within two years after the grant of administration, no action could have been maintained against him upon the note, we shall proceed to consider whether, notwithstanding this, the surety still remained liable ?

¶3It is well settled, that a discharge of the principal under a bankrupt law does not discharge the surety. 6 Mass. R. 33, Flagg vs. Tyler; 4 M. & S. 334, Welsh vs. Welsh; 2 M. & S. 39, Martin vs. Brecknell; 4 J. B. Moore 153, The London Assurance Company vs. Buckle.

¶4And a creditor is under no obligation to prove his debt under a commission of bankruptcy of the principal, unless the surety gives to the creditor an indemnity for the expense. 4 John. C. R. 132; 10 Vesey 414; 6 do. 734; 2 John. C. R. 562.

¶5The surety is the person who trusts the principal, and it is his business to see that the principal pays. A creditor is in no case bound to give notice to the surety that the debt is not paid. 2 Pick. 585, Hunt vs. Brigham; 2 Paige's R. 500, Sailly vs. Elmore; 6 Vesey 734, Wright vs. Simpson; 2 John. C. R. 559, King vs. Baldwin; 17 John. 403, S. C.

¶6Such being the general rules of law, it is very apparent that if the principal die, and his estate be administered in the insolvent course, the creditor is under no obligation to present his claim to the commissioners, and procure what he may from that estate. He has a right, in such a case, to look to the surety for the whole amount.

¶7It is the business of the surety to procure the creditor to lay his claim before the commissioners, or to pay the claim and then lay his own claim before the commissioners for the money he may have paid to the creditor.

¶8In England and New-York a surety may, upon certain terms, compel a creditor to proceed against the principal. *391The law is otherwise here. But this circumstance is immaterial in this case. In this state the surety may pay the debt when he pleases, and proceed against the principal himself.

¶9We are, therefore, of opinion that although no action could have been maintained against the executor upon the note at the time the plaintiff paid it, still the plaintiff remained liable upon the note, and that he is entitled to recover in this case whatever he paid to discharge himself from that liability,

¶10Judgment on the verdict.

/8/nh/389 · .json · Public domain