Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 N.H. 487

Allen v. Hubbard

Superior Court of New Hampshire

Decided July 15, 1837

Superior Court of New Hampshire · decided 1837-07-15

This was an appeal from a decree of the judge of probate in this county. Henry Allen died, leaving H. F. Allen, and N. F. Allen (the appellant) his heirs at law, and Mary Allen his widow. Samuel Hubbard, the appellee, married the widow, and on the 7th May, 1813, was appointed administrator de bonis non of the estate of the said Henry, deceased.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1837-07-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 7 later decisions — most recently January 1948

7 state decisions

30183718401850186018701880189019001910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Richardson, C. J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2It is manifest that the appellee in this case has received $340, for which he ought to have accounted, but for which he has not accounted. And if the heirs are not precluded by what has heretofore been done in the probate court, they are justly entitled to claim, and to have, two thirds of that sum, which is $226.67.

¶3The question then is, whether any thing has been done in the probate court which is conclusive upon this subject?

¶4It is not to be doubted, that a decision by a judge of probate, regularly made upon a matter within his jurisdiction, is conclusive against all the world. 6 N. H. R. 116, Bryant vs. Albee.

¶5It has been settled, that the decisions of the judge of probate can be proved only by a record of his proceedings. 3 N. H. R. 309, The Judge of Probate vs. Briggs.

¶6In this case the appellee rendered an account of rent received, but he did not render an account of the whole amount received. It does not appear that there was any controversy on the subject when the account was allowed by the judge, or even that his attention was called to the subject. It must be presumed that the sum omitted in the account was omitted by mistake and misapprehension, and that the mistake was not discovered by the judge, merely because the subject of the rent was not particularly examined by him, there being no objection in relation to the account of the rents.

¶7But in order to make the decision of the judge of probate conclusive on the subject, it should appear by the record that a claim was made before him to charge the appellee with the money omitted, and that the claim was disallowed. If this appeared of record it would be conclusive.

¶8We are of opinion that wherever there has been a manifest mistake in an account settled in the court of probate, it. is competent to the judge of probate at any time before a *490final settlement of the estate, to correct it in a subsequent account, provided there does not appear by the record to have been a particular adjudication upon the subject. Mistakes will sometimes unavoidably occur, and it is just and reasonable that they should be thus corrected. 9 Pick. 27, Stetson vs. Bass; 1 do. 157, Stearns vs. Stearns; 14 do. 105, Field vs. Hitchcock.

¶9The cause must be sent back to the judge of probate, with directions to reexamine the accounts, and correct all errors in respect to which there does not appear to have been a particular adjudication.

/8/nh/487 · .json · Public domain