Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 T.C. 1170

Faidley v. Commissioner

United States Tax Court

Decided June 11, 1947

United States Tax Court · decided 1947-06-11

The recoupment in 1941 of an investment in an oil venture which the petitioner had deducted as a loss in 1930, held taxable as ordinary income in 1941 to the extent that the deduction resulted in a reduction of taxable income for such prior year.

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“a complete loss, there being no salvage.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Mayfair Minerals, Inc. v. Commissioner

Relies on Dobson v. Commissioner · Dobson v. Commissioner

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decision will be entered under Rule 50 · Decided 1947-06-11

How this case has been cited

Cited by 11 later decisions — most recently December 1980

3 federal appellate ·

6019471950196019701980decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1OPINION.

LeMire, Judge:

¶2The petitioner contends, first, that the deduction of his investment in the oil venture was erroneously claimed and allowed in his return for 1930 because of his brother’s guaranty of the investment and that therefore the amount which he recovered from his brother’s estate in 1941 in satisfaction of that guaranty was not taxable income of that year, except as to the portion thereof which constituted interest, and that if taxable at all it constituted a capital gain and not ordinary income.

¶3We think that the facts support the respondent’s contention that the doctrine of estoppel is applicable. The petitioner took a deduction in his 1930 return which he now claims should not have been allowed. He stated in his return that his investment was “a complete loss, there being no salvage.” The petitioner, who had knowledge of the true facts, never undertook to correct the return. The return was accepted and audited as being correct. The evidence does not justify any finding that the respondent had knowledge of any facts other than those stated in the return. In short, there was no mutual mistake. The year of deduction is now closed by the statute of limitations and is not before us. It can not be reopened by waiver in this proceeding. We hold that the petitioner is estopped to contend that the recovery in 1941 does not constitute taxable income because of the fact that the deduction may have been erroneously claimed and allowed in 1930. Cf. Commissioner v. Liberty Bank & Trust Co., 59 Fed. (2d) 320. In that case estoppel was applied on facts similar to those in the instant case and the recoveries of debts erroneously reported as being worthless in a prior year were held to be chargeable to gross income for the years in which they were collected.

¶4The remaining questions are controlled by the principles set forth in Dobson v. Commissioner and Harwick v. Commissioner, 320 U. S. 489, affirming John V. Dobson, 46 B. T. A. 770, and H. J. Harwick, Docket No. 105790 (memorandum opinion, Mar. 30, 1942). Those cases hold that the recoupment of a loss which has been claimed and allowed as a deduction in the taxpayer’s return for a prior year is taxable as ordinary income in the year of the recovery to the extent that the deduction in the prior year served to reduce taxable income.

¶5The petitioner’s 1930 return shows a net income of $8,736.33 after deduction of $22,500 on account of loss in the oil venture. The return also shows that for normal tax purposes he had credits for dividends and personal exemptions aggregating $14,953.50. The Revenue Act of 1928, then in effect, provided a surtax exemption of $10,000.

¶6Applying the principles of the Dobson case, supra, it is apparent that the deduction in 1930 of the amount recovered in 1941 did effect an offset in taxable income and the taxpayer realized a tax benefit in 1930 on account of the deduction and to that extent we hold the 1941 recovery taxable as ordinary income.

¶7Reviewed by the Court.

¶8Decision will be entered under Rule 50.

Arnold, J., concurs only in the result.
/8/tc/1170 · .json · Public domain