Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

8 Wend. 545

Ames v. Webbers

New York Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1832

New York Supreme Court · decided 1832-01-15

Demurrer to plea. This is to an action of debt for the escape of one E. M. Blunt, arrested on an attachment from chancery for the non-payment of a bill of costs.

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently July 1863

4 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1832-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

By the Court, Nelson, J.

¶1It is objected that the action of debt will not lie against the sheriff in this case, on the ground that the declaration does not shew that the defendant, against whom the attachment issued, was committed to any jail, 2 R. S. 437, § 63, when thé escape was permitted. In the declaration it is stated that the defendant arrested Blunt, and had and detained him in his custody until he permitted him to escape and go at large. This is a sufficient averment within the meaning of the statute, for in judgment of law the prisoner is committed to jail when in the custody of the sheriff.

¶2*547The plea affords the defendant no protection. It has been repeatedly determined that unless the process is void upon which the sheriff has arrested the prisoner, he is bound to detain him in custody, and is responsible in an action for an escape, if he permits him to go at large. The distinction is between void and voidable process ; the latter is a justification to the officer to detain the prisoner until it is set aside by the party. One strong reason why the sheriff shall not take advantage of the error in issuing the process is, for aught that appears, the party does not wish to avail himself of it. 1 Cro. Eliz. 165. 2 Saund. 101, y, (n. 2.) 1 Cowen, 309. The following cases shew not only the above distinction, but that the process, according to the plea, is only voidable. Sears v. Wilkins, 1 Ves. sen. 195, Jackson, ex dem. Saunders, v. Cadwell, 1 Cowen, 644. Ontario Bank v. Hallett, 8 id. 192.

¶3Judgment for the plaintiffs upon demurrer, with leave to the defendant to amend on payment of costs.

/8/wend/545 · .json · Public domain