Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

80 Ky. 387

Werner v. Commonwealth

Court of Appeals of Kentucky

Decided September 26, 1882

Court of Appeals of Kentucky · decided 1882-09-26

Case 74 — INDICTMENT APPEAL FROM JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT. ‘ The evidence of the outcry of persons indicating the parties supposed to be guilty was incompetent. (10 Bush, 576; 1 Greenl., 108; Roscoe’s Grim. Ev., 20 and 21; 1 Taylor’s Ev., 531; Mockabee v. The Commonwealth, 78 Ky.) The proof objected to was competent to show— 1. That the parties were liable to arrest. 2.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently June 1935

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1882-09-26

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

JUDGE HINES

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2A peace officer, in attempting to make an arrest, met with resistance, and was seriously wounded. The officer ■was without warrant, and acting upon information that a felony had been previously committed by thp parties sought to be arrested. On the trial the court permitted the declarations of persons present at the time of the attempted arrest, *388aad indicating the parties supposed to be guilty, to go to the jury In evidence. Of this appellant complains, and his counsel insist that the case of Bradshaw v. Commonwealth is conclusive in his favor. In that case the court held, that upon the question of the guilt of the accused, the exclamation of persons not connected with the perpetration of the offense was not competent; but the question here is not as. to whether the accused had, in fact, committed a felony, but whether the officer had reasonable grounds to believe that a felony had been committed. Where the inquiry is only as to whether an offense has been committed by a. particular person, the exclamation of parties not connected with the perpetration of the offense is incompetent, because-not original, but hearsay evidence; but when the question is whether the party acted prudently, wisely, or in good faith, the information on which he acted, whether true or false, is oi'iginal evidence.

¶3We see no error in the giving or refusing instructions.

¶4J udgment affirmed.

/80/ky/387 · .json · Public domain