Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

80 Wis. 414

In re Ryan

Wisconsin Supreme Court

Decided November 17, 1891

Wisconsin Supreme Court · decided 1891-11-17

<p> Constitutional law: Act creating debts or malting appropriations: New judicial circuits. </p> <p>Ch. 488. Laws of 1887, creating the fiftéenth judicial circuit, is a valid law. McDonald v. State, ante, p. 407, followed.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1891-11-17

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently May 1964

3 state decisions

1018911900191019201930194019501960decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1The following opinion was filed October 20, 1891:

Per Curiam.

¶2In May, 1891, an information was duly filed in the municipal court of the city and county of Ash-land, charging the petitioner, Charles Ryan, with the crime of burglary, and he was thereupon arrested and held to answer such charge. He interposed an affidavit of the prejudice of the judge of such court, and the place of trial of the accused on such information was changed to the circuit court for Ashland county. The trial of the petitioner has been postponed to the next December term of the circuit court. He now applies for a writ prohibiting Hon. John K. Parish from presiding at his trial, and prohibiting such *415circuit court from trying him. The grounds assigned for issuing the writ prayed for are that the place of trial should not have been changed to the circuit court for Ashland county, but should have been changed to the circuit court of some other county or circuit; and that ch. 488, Laws of 1887, which attempts to create the fifteenth judicial circuit, is not a valid law; and hence that Judge Paeish, who was elected under that statute, is not the judge of the circuit court for Ashland county or any other county.

¶3In McDonald v. State, ante, p. 407, we hold that ch. 488, Laws of 1887, is a valid law, and hence that the fifteenth judicial circuit was lawfully created, that Ashland county is a part of it, and that Judge PaRish is the duly elected and qualified judge of the circuit court in the counties constituting that circuit.

¶4As to the change of venue, it is sufficient to say that ch. 94, Laws of 1889, creating such municipal court, provides, in sec. 2 thereof, that, “ in case of the change of the place of trial ... of any criminal case begun by information, . . . said case shall be removed to the circuit court for Ashland county, unless such change is taken on the ground of prejudice of the people of said county,” etc.

¶5No valid reason for issuing the writ appearing, the petition must be denied.

¶6Upon a motion for a rehearing there was a brief by Geo. H. McCloud, attorney, and Rublee A. Cole, of counsel.

¶7The motion was denied November 17, 1891.

/80/wis/414 · .json · Public domain