Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

81 Ind. 67

McElhoes v. Dale

Indiana Supreme Court

Decided November 15, 1881

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1881-11-15

<p>New Tbial. — Practice.—Recovery.—A motion for a new trial, on the ground that the finding is contrary to law, or to the evidence, presents no question in reference to the amount of the recovery.</p>

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently May 1889

1 state decisions

Relies on Spurrier v. Briggs · Rosenbaum v. McThomas

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1881-11-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Woods, J.

¶1The only error assigned is the overruling of the appellant’s motion for a new trial. The causes stated in the motion for a new trial are:

¶21st. The finding of the court is contrary to law.

¶32d. The finding is contrary to the evidence.

¶43d. The finding is contrary to the law and the evidence.

¶5The entire brief of the appellant is addressed to the proposition that the amount of the recovery was too large by the sum of one hundred and fifty dollars, and interest thereon from the date when it ought, as is claimed, to have been credited on the note sued on, it being conceded that the finding in favor of the plaintiff for a small amount is right. The causes alleged in the motion for a new trial, it is manifest, do not present the question discussed. In order to raise a question as to the amount of damages, or of the recovery, the new trial must be moved for on the ground of excessive damages, or for error in the assessment of the amount of the recovery. Code 1852, sec. 352; R. S. 1881, sec. 559; Spurrier v. Briggs, 17 Ind. 529; Rosenbaum v. McThomas, 34 Ind. 331.

¶6Judgment affirmed, with costs.

¶7On Petition for a Rehearing.

Woods, J.

¶8Counsel for the appellant now say that “any

¶9concession made in their original brief that anything is due on the note in suit, or that a judgment for any sum whatever should have been rendered in favor of the appellee, is not warranted by the evidence,” and ask a rehearing, in order that the case may be considered from the standpoint so suggested.

¶10We are not disposed to depart from the rule which forbids the raising of new questions, especially by the appellant, in a petition for a rehearing.

¶11The petition overruled, with costs.

/81/ind/67 · .json · Public domain