¶1In the opinion of the court there must be a new trial in the present case, for the reason that the court of common pleas ruled absolutely that the award was a bar to the plaintiff’s action. The submission was an oral one, and the plaintiff offered to show that he only submitted to arbitration the matter of the drains connected with the houses of Preble and Lovett. If such was in fact the submission, then the award was no bar, and this would be so irrespectively of the question of a revocation of the submission. Exceptions sustained.
81 Mass. 59
Cook v. Jaques
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
Decided January 15, 1860
Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1860-01-15
<p>A matter not in terms included in a written award rendered upon an oral submission may be shown by paroi evidence not to have been in fact brought to the notice of the arbitrators or considered by them. .</p>
Decided 1860-01-15