Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

825 So. 2d 1230

State v. Johnson

Louisiana Court of Appeal

Decided May 29, 2002

Louisiana Court of Appeal · decided 2002-05-29

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently August 2016

2 state decisions

Relies on 742 So. 2d 722 - State v. Warren

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 2002-05-29

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

| MURRAY, J.,

¶1dissents in part and assigns reasons.

¶2Although I agree that Mr. Johnson’s conviction should be affirmed, I dissent *1235from the affirmation of the trial court’s departure from the minimum sentence in this case. A downward departure from the minimum sentence under the Habitual Offender Law should occur only in rare cases. State v. Warren, 99-0557, p. 8 (La.App.4 Cir. 9/8/99), 742 So.2d 722, 727. In my opinion, this is not such a case.

¶3At sentencing, the trial court described Mr. Johnson as an “obviously incorrigible habitual offender” who had at least five convictions for distributing cocaine over a seven year span and who during that same span was convicted for theft over five hundred dollars and for simple escape. The trial court also characterized Mr. Johnson as a “habitual drug dealer” who has “habitually thumbed his nose at the judicial system.” Despite those strong findings supporting the minimum sentence, the trial court found it appropriate to make a downward departure from that sentence based on one factor; to-wit: “the criminal history of Mr. Johnson indicates that there has been no instances of violent behavior” or “behavior which directly threatens the welfare of any one else.” The trial court’s reliance on that factor was misplaced. As we noted in Warren, supra,“[vjiolence and/or the lack thereof has already been factored into the minimum sentence under the Habitual Offender Law.” 99-0557 at p. 10, 742 So.2d at 728.

¶4|2Given that the trial court s reasons do not support a departure from the minimum, I would vacate Mr. Johnson’s sentence and remand for re-sentencing.

/825/so2d/1230 · .json · Public domain