Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

84 Vt. 51

Lumbra v. Campbell

Supreme Court of Vermont

Decided November 16, 1910

Supreme Court of Vermont · decided 1910-11-16

Trover for a clapboard mill, consisting of a clapboard saw, with lathe and crane attachments, a dressing machine for planing clapboards, and a butting saw. Plea, the general issue. Trial by court at the March Term, 1910, Franklin County, Taylor, J., presiding. Judgment for the defendant. The plaintiffs excepted. The opinion states the case.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently November 1914

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1910-11-16

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Rowell, C. J.

¶1This is trover for a clapboard sawmill. The case was tried by the court, and judgment went for the defendant.

¶2.The plaintiffs let the mill to the defendant for the season of 1908. The defendant finished the cut of logs for that season *52in April, and notified the plaintiffs. Then, by mutual agreement, the mill was moved from the defendant’s sawmill, where he had used it, and stored in his shed some rods away. In February, 1909, he moved it back to his sawmill, and set it up for use in sawing another year’s stock of logs, and used it there till June, 1909, when it was destroyed by fire without his fault.

¶3The defendant did not ask permission to use the mill another year, and the plaintiffs did not expressly consent to its use, but they knew it was being used, and did not object to its further use, and the defendant understood he was using it under the arrangement originally made.

¶4These facts point strongly to the probable conclusion that the plaintiffs were willing the defendant should use the mill the second year, and were satisfied to let the use go on as it did, for otherwise they would most likely have objected when they found it out. So the court below not only could fairly have inferred that much, but ought to have inferred it; and therefore this Court will presume it did, to the end that the judgment may stand and not fall.

¶5Judgment affirmed.

/84/vt/51 · .json · Public domain