Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

85 Mass. 491

Stevens v. Cunningham

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 15, 1862

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1862-01-15

<p>A- B. contracted for a steam engine and boiler, to be of a certain power, and at the time when the same were delivered paid a portion of the stipulated price, taking a receipt which showed that the money then paid was received by the maker “in part payment for the steam engine and boiler sold to A. B. by me,” and contained also a provision that if they should not prove to be of the power specified, the maker should repay the money and take them back, and if he should fail to do so, A. B. should have a right to sell them. On trial they proved not to be of the power specified, but the maker on request refused to repay the money and take them away. Several months afterwards, A. B. allowed the maker to take away and use the boiler, on his agreeing to pay for the use of it; and after removing it, the maker mortgaged it. Held) that the title thereto was in A. B., and that he could maintain replevin therefor, although he authorized the maker to sell it at the time of allowing him to take away and use the same.</p>

Decided 1862-01-15

Chapman, J.

¶1It appears by the receipt of Johnson that he sold the engine and boiler to the plaintiff, with an obligation to take them back in the contingency that the engine should be insufficient to drive the plaintiff’s scow according to the terms stipulated. But he never took them back, and so they remained the property of the plaintiff. The boiler was afterwards leased to Johnson ; for the permission given to him to take and use it by paying rent for it constituted a lease. If authority was given him to sell it, such authority would not include a right to mortgage it as security for his own debt. Gen. Sts. c. 54, § 4, relate to consignees and factors, but not to lessees; and to deposits and pledges, but not mortgages. And as the statute is in derogation of the rights of owners, and gives effect to fraudulent transfers, as against the owners, it is not to be extended by construction.

¶2 Exceptions overruled.

/85/mass/491 · .json · Public domain