Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

85 Miss. 687

Wilson v. State

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided November 15, 1904

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1904-11-15

From the circuit court of, second district, Ooahoma county. Hon. Samuel O. Oook, Judge. Wilson, the appellant, was indicted, tried, and convicted of an attempt to commit forgery, and appealed to the supreme court. The opinion of the court fully states the facts of the case. Forgery is defined as “the false making’ or materially altering, with intention to defraud, any writing, which, if genuine, might apparently be of legal efficacy for the foundation of a legal liability.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1904-11-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 6 later decisions — most recently February 1981

6 state decisions

20190419101920193019401950196019701980decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Calhoon, J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2Wilson was convicted of an attempt to commit forgery, the court below properly charging the jury that it could not convict of the crime itself. The instrument of which attempt to commit forgery.is predicated is" a draft for “two and 50-100 dollars,” as written out in the body of it, having in the upper right-hand corner the figures “$2.50-100,” as is customary in checks, drafts, •and notes, and having plainly printed and stamped on the face of the instrument the words “Ten Dollars or Less.” Wilson, with a pen, put the figure “1” before the figure “2” in the upper right-hand corner, making these immaterial figures appear “$12.50” instead of “$2.50,” and undertook to negotiate it as $12.50. This was not forgery, because it was an immaterial part of the paper, and because it could not possibly have injured anybody. In order to constitute the crime, there must be not only the intent to commit it, but also an act of alteration done to a material part, so that injury might result. Rembert v. State, 53 Ala., 467 (25 Am. St. Rep., 639); Roode v. State, 5 Neb., 174 (25 Am. St. Rep., 475); 1 Bish. New Crim. Law, secs. 572—740; Commonwealth v. Wilson, 2 Gray, 70; State v. Pierce, 8 Iowa, 235; People v. Galloway, 17 Wend., 540; Anderson v. State, 20 Tex. App., 595; State v. Smith, 8 Yerg., 150; Howell v. State, 37 Tex., 591; Barnum v. State, 15 Ohio, 717 (45 Am. Dec., 601); People v. Tomlinson, 35 Gal., 503; State v. Briggs, 34 Vt., 501; State v. Corley, 63 Tenn., 410; Cox v. State, 66 Miss., 14 (5 South. Rep., 618); State v. Means, 47 La. Ann., 1535 (18 Souths Rep., 514); Commonwealth v. Bailey, 1 Mass., 62 (2 Am. Dec., 3); Commonwealth v. Stevens, 1 Mass., 203. These authorities might be numerously added to, but it is enough to say now that they sustain what we have said, and establish also that an instrument void on its face is not the subject of forgery, and that, in order to be so subject, it must have been capable of working injury if it had been genuine, and that the marginal numbers *691and figures are not part of the instrument, and their alteration' is not forgery.

¶3This being true, can the conviction of an attempt to commit forgery be sustained in the case before us ? We think not. No purpose appears to change anything on the paper except the figures in the margin, and this could not have done any hurt. Our statute (Code 1892, § 1106) confines the crime of forgery to instances where “any person may be affected, bound, or in any way injured in his person or property.” This is nqt,sa6br a case, and sec. 974 forbids convicting of an attempt “when it shall appear that the Crime intended or the offense attempted was perpetrated.” In this record the innocuous prefix of the figure “1 ” on the margin was fully accomplished, and no other effort appears, and, if genuine, could have done no harm; and so the appellant is guiltless, in law, of the crime of which he was convicted.

¶4Reversed and remanded.

/85/miss/687 · .json · Public domain