Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

85 Neb. 478

Sewall v. Whiton

Nebraska Supreme Court

Decided December 14, 1909

Nebraska Supreme Court · decided 1909-12-14

<p>Appeal from the district court for Rock county: James J. Harrington, Judge.</p>

Relies on Schick v. Whitcomb · Fisher v. Fisher · Phillips v. Dorris

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Appeal dismissed · Decided 1909-12-14

How this case has been cited

Cited by 6 later decisions — most recently May 2022

6 state decisions

201909191019201930194019501960197019801990200020102020decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1This is an action in partition. The plaintiffs alleged that they were each the owner of an undivided one-third of a certain parcel of land. The defendant admitted she was in possession of the premises, but denied the title of the plaintiffs to an undivided one-half interest to the property; asserted title thereto in herself; prayed that the title be quieted in her, and that the plaintiffs be enjoined from asserting any right, claim or interest in the same. She further prayed for partition and an accounting. The reply denied these allegations. The action was tried to the court, which found for the defendant; granted her affirmative relief; ordered the premises partitioned, and appointed referees to make partition. This appeal is from this judgment and order.

¶2Defendant has filed a motion to dismiss the appeal, asserting that the judgment from which the appeal is attempted to be taken is an interlocutory order and that this court has no jurisdiction to pass upon the question presented by the record.

¶3We deem it advisable, in this connection, to point out the proper method of practice in appeals in partition cases where an issue is raised upon a question of title.

¶4In Seymour v. Ricketts, 21 Neb, 240, it is pointed out *479that it is a general rule in an action for partition where the title of plaintiff is denied that the partition proceedings will he suspended to give the plaintiff a reasonable opportunity to try his title at law, and the court will, in the meantime, retain the petition. This case was followed in Phillips v. Dorris, 56 Neb. 293. In Schimpf v. Rhodewald, 62 Neb. 105, the action was begun as an action for partition; but, when it was disclosed that a question of title was involved, the court properly ordered that the title be first tried as in an action of ejectment. After-wards, by agreement of parties, a jury was waived and the issues as to title tried to the court, and at the same time the court also tried the right of partition. The proceedings in partition were suspended upon bringing the action here, and, upon the judgment being affirmed, the case was remanded for further partition proceedings. See, also, Fisher v. Fisher, 80 Neb. 145. In neither of those cases was the question now before us raised.

¶5We think there is no conflict in the cases to which our attention has been called. When a petition has been filed asking for partition, if the plaintiff’s title is controverted, the parties have a right to suspend the partition proceedings until the question of title is determined, either by a jury or by the court. A judgment rendered upon the issue of title alone is a final judgment, from which appeal will lie, and which may be reviewed by this court while the partition proceedings are suspended. If, however, the parties unite the issues and litigate the question of title and the right to partition at the same time, and the court determines both questions in the same judgment, such a judgment or order is only one step in the partition proceedings, is interlocutory in its nature, and cannot be reviewed until the final decree of partition, or until sale and confirmation. Schick v. Whitcomb, 68 Neb. 784. The order complained of in this case is of this interlocutory character, and cannot be reviewed until the end of the partition proceedings. Skallberg v. Skallberg, 84 Neb, 717; Vrana v. Vrana, ante, p. 128.

¶6*480The appeal therefore is premature, and the motion must be sustained.

¶7Appeal dismissed.

/85/neb/478 · .json · Public domain