¶1This was an action of ejectment brought by "W. IT. Milner, Emma J. Mosley, John L. Milner, James L. Milner, E. B. Milner, T. P. Milner, Ernest Milner and Kitty C. Stocks, heirs at law of James Milner, deceased, against A.-6. B. Yandivere, for the recovery of a certain tract of land described in the declaration. By an amendment the names of Mrs. Mosley and Mrs. Stocks, were stricken from the declaration. The defendant-filed the plea of not guilty, and also the further plea that he had been in the actual and continuous adverse possession of the premises under written evidence of title for more than seven years before the commencement of the suit, and that the plaintiffs’ right of action, was barred by the statute of prescription. He also-filed an equitable plea setting up certain equities as a reason why the plaintiffs were not entitled to recover; which will be found in the report of the case. Both sides submitted evidence to the jury which it is unnecessary to detail here. Under the charge of the court the jury returned a verdict for the defendant. The plaintiffs moved for a new trial on the several grounds set out *544therein, which was overruled by the court, and they excepted.
¶2
¶3Under the facts of the case we think the court erred in giving the above in charge to the jury. It will be seen that the jury were instructed that if the mother of the plaintiffs sold the land to the defendants or either of them, and used the money received from the land in the support and maintenance of the plaintiffs or any of them, the.plaintiffs could not recover; also, that if for any reason any of the plaintiffs could not recover, none of them could recover. It is true this court has held in several cases that where tenants in common bring a joint action for the recovery of land, and it is *545shown at the trial that either of them has no title or right of entry and possession, the action fails, although the others may have the title and the right of entry and possession. De Vaughn v. McLeroy, 82 Ga. 713, and cases there cited. This is the law of our State where the action is purely legal; and it will be seen by reference to the cases cited that they were all legal actions, and in none of them was an equitable defence filed. But we think that where plaintiffs bring a joint action of ejectment, and the defendant does not rely merely upon a legal right to defeat the action, but sets up an equitable' right against the right of any or all of the plaintiffs to recover, the rule does not apply, and the action does not fail unless the equitable defence prevails against all the plaintiffs. If the defendant shows an equity superior to the legal title of all the plaintiffs, none of them can recover; if he shows an equity superior only to the legal title of some of the plaintiffs, and not to that of the others, the former cannot recover, while the latter can. In other words, if A, B and C, being tenants in common, bring a joint action against D, for the recovery of land, and D shows a superior equity to the legal title of B and C, and not to that of A, A can recover and B and C cannot. This rule naturally and of necessity arises from the blending of legal and equitable jurisdictions. Under the old practice, in an action of ’ejectment at law, a recovery could only be had upon the legal title to land. The holder of an equitable title could neither support the action nor set up his equitable title as a basis of affirmative relief, or to defeat a recovery based upon the legal title. The rights of the holder of the equitable title could only be asserted and established in equity. Injunctions were frequently granted to restrain ejectment by the holder of the legal title during the pendency of the proceedings in equity upon the equitable title. The defend*546ant may now, under our practice, interpose equitable as well as legal titles or defences; and when equitable defences are set up against legal titles, the same rule and measure of justice is. to be applied as if the proceeding was in equity. Sedgwick and "Wait on Trial of Title to Land, §485. "Under the old practice, if the defendant’s equity was superior to the legal title of either or any of the plaintiffs, the court would enjoin those plaintiffs from prosecuting their action at. law against the defendant, but would refuse to enjoin those whose legal title was superior to the defendant’s'equity. And therefore, as the defendant, under our practice, can set up his equity by an equitable plea to an action at law, we think that where he files such plea, the common law rule that all shall recover or none does not prevail. Indeed it has been so held by this court. In the case of Humph v. Truelove, 66 Ga. 480, it is said: “"Whatsoever might be held to be the rule as to a joint demise, where the general issue only is pleaded, it is unnecessary in 'this case to decide, as under our liberal practice, equitable pleas involving other .matters than title may be introduced and adjudicated. This very right necessarily abrogates any such common law rule.”- See also Pomeroy on Nemedies and Nemedial Nights, §§209-215; Allen v. Logan,' 10 S. W. (Mo.) 149-151. ■
¶4
¶5
¶6
¶7Judgment reversed.