Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

86 Wis. 552

57 N.W 374

Weld v. Johnson Manufacturing Co.

Wisconsin Supreme Court

Decided November 29, 1893

Wisconsin Supreme Court · decided 1893-11-29

The facts are stated in the opinion. The plaintiffs appealed from an order striking out their demurrer to a counterclaim in the answer. , They argued, among other things, that by the transactions alleged in the counterclaim E. S. Johnson abdicated and waived his right to possession of the land in question as surviving partner. Wellborn v. Coon, 57 Ind. 270, 2Y3-4; 2 Pates, Partn. sec. 717; Griffin v. Spence, 69 Ala. 393; 16 Am. & Eng. Ency. of Law, 1156.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently May 1905

1 district · 2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Ejectment · Decided 1893-11-29

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

LyoN, O. J.

¶1 I concur with Mr. Justice OktoN.

Winslow, J.

¶2 My views in this case are, in brief, as follows: The right of a surviving partner to dispose of the partnership real estate, so far as necessary to pay partnership debts and close its affairs, is undoubted. In this case the answer shows, to my mind, no such state of facts, but rather a conveyance to a corporation, composed of the surviving partner and the widow of the deceased partner, for the purpose of continuing the old business under a change of name, with the entire assets of the old firm. I think the surviving partner, as such, had no right to make such a conveyance, and that the corporation, having notice of the purpose, acquired no title to the real estate in question thereby. However, the majority of the court were of opinion, as I understand it, that the equitable defense stated in the answer (as prescribed by sec. 3018, S. & B. Ann. Stats.), while insufficient in this action to be the basis of *563 affirmative relief, especially in the absence of essential parties, is still sufficient to defeat this action of ejectment, leaving the parties to litigate their equitable rights in an appropriate action in equity, when all the necessary parties may be brought before the court. Under this view of the law it seems clear to my mind that the proper judgment is that of affirmance.

¶3 A motion for a rehearing was denied March 16, 1894.

/86/wis/552 · .json · Public domain