Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

87 Cal. 543

Clarke v. Reis

California Supreme Court

Decided January 30, 1891

California Supreme Court · decided 1891-01-30

<p>Appeal from a judgment of the Superior Court of the city and county of San Francisco,</p> <p>The facts are stated in the opinion.</p>

Relies on Pennie v. Res · Pennie v. Reis

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1891-01-30

How this case has been cited

Cited by 17 later decisions — most recently November 1957

17 state decisions

601891190019101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Foote, C.

¶1This action was brought for the purpose of forcing, by writ of mandate, the respondent to pay the appellant, who was the assignee of a claim of a dismissed police-officer, one Pugh, the amount of $256 principal, and costs and damages to the amount of $25.

¶2This sum of money was claimed under and by virtue of an act of the legislature approved April 1, 1878. (Stats. 1878, p. 879.)

¶3It is asserted that the two dollars per month which the police-officer claims to have paid into the fund held by the treasurer was money in which he had a vested *544right, and that on his discharge he was entitled to have it returned to him or his representative.

¶4The petition was demurred to as not stating facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action; the demurrer was sustained, and the writ dismissed. From the judgment rendered in the premises this appeal is taken.

¶5The statute under which this right is set up by the plaintiff has received construction from the appellate court of this state in Pennie v. Reis, 80 Cal. 269, and from the supreme court of the United States in the same case on writ of error. (132 U. S. 471.) These cases hold that a police-officer, such' as the assignor of the appellant, never had any claim on the fund involved here, except upon the happening of certain contingencies, mentioned in the act of the legislature of California to which we have just adverted, under which act alone could any right have vested in the plaintiff or his assignor.

¶6The voluminous and argumentative petition filed herein does not, in our opinion, state such facts as bring the appellant within any of the contingencies of the statute which he invokes, and we therefore advise that the judgment be affirmed.

¶7Hayne, C., and Belcher, C., concurred.

¶8The Court. — For the reasons given in the foregoing opinion, the judgment is affirmed.

/87/cal/543 · .json · Public domain