Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist
← 87 F.2d 842 - Mutual Life Ins. v. Cunningham

Mutual Life Ins. v. Cunningham’s Empirical Analysis

87 F.2d 842 · 1937

Citation profile

6
cited by 6 later decisions
2
states following
April 1955
most recently cited

2 federal appellate · 1 district · 3 state decisions

Relationships

Relies on Matthews v. Rodgers · Enelow v. New York Life Insurance · Pennsylvania v. Williams · Orient Ins Co of Hartford Conn v. Daggs · Di Giovanni v. Camden Fire Insurance

Most-quoted passages

The sentences later courts lift from this opinion, ranked by how many decisions quote each — the parts of the opinion doing the work. These counts are smaller than the citation total above because most of the 6 citing decisions cite the case generally; a passage count includes only decisions quoting that exact language verbatim.

  1. ““ # * * as to whether this statute goes merely to the remedy, as held in the Nelson Case, or is a rule of substantive law passing into the contract, as held in the Mickel Case. If this conflict exists, we must accept the rule of the Mickel Case as being the latest pronouncement of the Supreme Court of the state. If this is the situation, the statutory provision becomes a part of the contract in the sense that the contract is governed thereby and United States courts acting in equity will enforce it. [Citing authorities.] “However, the above conflict may be more seeming than real when we give regard to the method and effect of the statute. The statute declares an ‘estoppel’ in a certain fact situation. This estoppel is positive and not rebuttable. When the fact situation exists (as here), the statute exerts its full force and the provisions in the contract relating to innocent false statements in the application for insurance lose all influence whatever may be the fact as to the truth or falsity of such statements. Thus the effect of the statute is, in a practical sense, to change the contract while the method of bringing about that effect is through estoppel which is often regarded as remedial. This is that character of estoppel which is really ‘a rule of substantive law masquerading as a rule of evidence.’ [Citing authorities.] Where a. statute is of this character it does not limit the equitable jurisdiction of the' United States courts and will be recognized and enforced i”
    2 later decisions quote this exact passage · from the majority
  2. ““The estoppel created by the statute is broad and sweeping, and in express terms includes both the time of issuance and the time of the delivery of the policy. * * * “Two applicable and obvious legal rules may be briefly stated, as follows: (1) The legislature may, by proper enactment, make the report or certificate of the company’s medical examiner to the effect that the applicant is a fit subject for insurance conclusive, and may deny the company the right to set up ill health on the part of the insured as a defense existing at the time of such medical examination and the issuance of the policy, or at the time of the delivery thereof to the insured, even though the illness may have arisen prior or subsequent to the medical examination and the report of the examiner to the company; (2) that an insurance company may not contract with an applicant for insurance in disregard of such enactment, and bind him thereto. “The provisions of the application relied upon as a defense in this case are not, per se, invalid, under Section 8770, Code of 1924; but, if the statute is applicable where the illness arose wholly subsequent to the date of the medical examination and report of the medical examiner, then they cease to be effective immediately upon the delivery of the policy and the acceptance thereof by the insured. It follows from what we have already said that an' insurance company has a right to contract with an applicant that the policy shall not go into effect until delivery the”
    1 later decision quote this exact passage · from the majority
  3. ““Two applicable and obvious legal rules may be briefly stated, as follows: (1) The legislature may, by proper enactment, make the report or certificate of the company’s medical examiner to the effect that the applicant is a fit subject for insurance conclusive, and may deny the company the right to set up ill health on the part of the insured as a defense * * * (2) that an insurance company may not contract with an applicant for insurance in disregard of such enactment, and bind him thereto.””
    1 later decision quote this exact passage · from the majority

How this case has been treated — in progress

Whether each later court followed, distinguished, criticized, or overruled this decision. The treatment classification (task #35) runs highest-cited cases first and lights up here as it reaches this one.