Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

87 Miss. 667

Johnson v. Hall

Mississippi Supreme Court

Decided November 15, 1905

Mississippi Supreme Court · decided 1905-11-15

Erom tbe chancery court of Rankin county. Hon. Robert B. Mates, Chancellor. Sarah Hall, the appellee, was the complainant in the court below; Johnson and others, the appellants, were defendants there. Erom a decree in favor of complainant the defendants appealed to the supreme court. Sarah Hall, the complainant, an illiterate negro woman, was the owner of certain property in Rankin county.

Decided 1905-11-15

Truly, J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2None of the assignments of error possess any merit. It has been heretofore decided that Code 1892, § 1764, is a restrictive, not an enlarging, statute. Dickerson v. Askew, 82 Miss., 436 (34 South. Rep., 157).

¶3The instant case clearly does not fall within its scope; but if it did, appellants did not bring themselves within its terms. There was no agreement in writing to have the witnesses examined in open court, nor was the notice to that effect filed “before *669any depositions have been taken,” as required by the statute. The notice was filed o-n October 16, 1903, while the certificate of the commissioner shows that the taking of depositions commenced on March 13, 1903. Hence, it was not error to refuse to permit the oral examination of certain witnesses when the cause came on for final hearing.

¶4The action of the chancellor in permitting certain pension affidavits to be introduced in evidence, if error at all, does not constitute reversible error under the facts of this record. At most, they were but cumulative evidence of slight probative force, and the case of complainant had already been clearly proven by testimony of indisputable competency. The case made by the record is simply a bald, palpable, brazen attempt to defraud an ignorant woman of her home by a trick. Such a transaction could never be upheld by any court of conscience.

¶5The decree is affirmed.

/87/miss/667 · .json · Public domain