Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

896 S.W.2d 799

Strut Cam Dimensions, Inc. v. Sutton

Texas Court of Appeals, 13th District

Decided February 9, 1995

Texas Court of Appeals, 13th District · decided 1995-02-09

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently September 1996

2 state decisions

Relies on North East Independent School District v. Aldridge · Stoner v. Thompson · Mafrige v. Ross

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1995-02-09

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1OPINION

PER CURIAM.

¶2The transcript in this case includes a post-answer default judgment that neither addresses the defendants’ counterclaims nor contains a Mother Hubbard clause denying all relief not expressly granted. Whether we have jurisdiction over this matter depends on the applicability of the Aldridge presumption to post-answer default judgments. See North East Indep. Sch. Dist. v. Aldridge, 400 S.W.2d 893, 897-98 (Tex.1966) (discussing circumstances under which a judgment will be presumed final and appealable notwithstanding the omission of a Mother Hubbard clause); see also Stoner v. Thompson, 578 S.W.2d 679, 682 (Tex.1979) (defining post-answer default as failure to appear at trial after filing answer).

¶3The Dallas Court of Appeals, the only court to have specifically addressed this issue, has extended the Aldridgepresumption of finality to post-answer default judgments. Thomas v. Dubovy-Longo, 786 S.W.2d 506, 507 (Tex.App.—Dallas 1990, writ denied); see also Schnitzius v. Koons, 813 S.W.2d 213, 216 (Tex.App.—Dallas 1991, no writ) (citing Thomaswith approval). The Thomascourt based its decision on language from Aldridgethat applied the presumption of finality to cases “regularly set for a conventional trial on the merits.” Thomas, 786 S.W.2d at 507 (quoting from Aldridge, 400 S.W.2d at 897) (emphasis supplied).

¶4Since Aldridge, however, the supreme court has backed away from this language; the court has shifted focus from whether the dispute was set for trial to whether a conventional trial was actually conducted. See, e.g., Martinez v. Humble Sand & Gravel, Inc., 875 S.W.2d 311, 312 (Tex.1994) (“After a conventional trial on the merits, even absent clear language, the appellate court may draw the inference the judgment was meant to be final.”) (emphasis supplied); Mafrige v. Ross, 866 S.W.2d 590, 592 (Tex.1993) (“the Mother Hubbard language from [Aldridge ] was limited to conventional trial on the merits”); Houston Health Clubs v. First Court of Appeals, 722 S.W.2d 692, 693 (Tex.1986) (“Following conventional trial on the merits, the judgment is presumed final.”); Teer v. Dud-*801dlesten, 664 S.W.2d 702, 704 (Tex.1984) (disapproving application of Aldridgepresumption absent “a conventional trial regularly set for trial on the merits”); accord Walker v. Sharpe, 807 S.W.2d 442, 445 (Tex.App.—Corpus Christi 1991, no writ) (“In determining whether the judgment is final, different presumptions apply depending on whether the judgment follows a conventional trial on the merits or results from default or summary proceedings. Following a conventional trial on the merits, the judgment is presumed final.”)

¶5Because the supreme court no longer emphasizes trial setting as the act that attaches the presumption of finality, we must consider whether a post-answer default involves a conventional trial. In Stoner, the supreme court concluded that a post-answer default is not “a judgment upon trial ... [but] a form of ‘judgment by default.’ ” Stoner, 578 S.W.2d at 682 (quoting Mullen v. Roberts, 423 S.W.2d 576, 579 (Tex.1968)). Significantly, the Aldridgepresumption does not apply to default judgments. Houston Health Clubs, 722 S.W.2d at 692.

¶6Having considered the Thomasopinion of the Dallas Court of Appeals, we conclude that the presumption of finality does not apply to post-answer default judgments. We agree with the Dallas court that the nonde-faulting party in a post-answer default must present evidence “as in a judgment upon a trial.” Thomas, 786 S.W.2d at 507 (quoting Stoner, 578 S.W.2d at 682) (emphasis supplied). Nevertheless, post-answer default judgments do not follow a conventional trial on the merits because such judgments are not, in any event, “a judgment upon trial.” Stoner, 578 S.W.2d at 682; c.f. Thomas, 786 S.W.2d at 507-08 (Enoch, C.J., concurring) (noting that the Aldridgepresumption “should not balance upon so tenuous a fulcrum as whether the case was regularly set for trial” but then focussing on whether there was an “actual” trial rather than a conventional trial on the merits).

¶7The post-answer default judgment in the instant case neither denies the defendants’ counterclaims nor contains a Mother Hubbard clause. Absent the Aldridgepresumption of finality, therefore, this judgment remains interlocutory until severed from, or modified to address, the defendants’ counterclaims. Accordingly, we have no jurisdiction over this appeal.

/896/sw2d/799 · .json · Public domain