Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

9 Ala. 613

Thornton v. Winter

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided January 15, 1846

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1846-01-15

<p>1. The levy of an attachment on a pair of shoes, if really made, and the shoes of any value, is sufficient. If the levy is fictitious, or colorable, it would be quashed by the Court to which it was returned on motion.</p> <p>3. The return of the sheriff, that he has levied on certain property by virtue of the writ, is an affirmation that it is the property of the defendant.</p>

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently June 1852

3 state decisions

Relies on Kirksey v. Bates

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1846-01-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

ORMOND, J.

¶1By the attachment law of this State, the attachment may be levied “ on the lands, goods, chattels or effects of the defendant, or it may be levied on a debt due him in the hands of his debtor, who is garnisheed to appear and answer.”

¶2The levy of the attachment, is by the statute made equivalent to the service of ordinary process, and is in law the appearance of the defendant. The levy on a pair of shoes, was, if really made, and the shoes were of any value, a sufficient levy to sustain the attachment. They are the goods of the defendant, and therefore within the terms of the statute. If the levy was fictitious, or merely colorable, it would have been discharged by the court to which the return was made, on motion to qudsh, or set it aside. The objection cannot be taken here, because we cannot know that the articles levied on arq of no value.

¶3The return of the sheriff, that he had levied on certain property by virtue of the writ, is an affirmation that it is the property of the defendant. To this effect, see the decisions cited by the counsel for the defendant in error, and especially Kirksey v. Bates, 1 Ala. 303. The other assignments of error are not insisted on.

¶4Let the judgment be affirmed.

/9/ala/613 · .json · Public domain